Why is 'solar power vs utilities' such a hot topic? | RenewEconomy

Why is ‘solar power vs utilities’ such a hot topic?

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

The distributed solar revolution is afoot, and talk of war, fighting, revolution, and the death of utilities is so hot right now. But why?

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


Many of our most popular articles of the year concern the “fight” between solar power beneficiaries and utilities. The distributed solar revolution is afoot, and talk of war, fighting, revolution, and the death of utilities is hot. Sometimes it seems to go a little further than is warranted, but I guess that’s how you get a revolution going, and it certainly seems to resonate well with readers.

I’ve just been wondering, why do such stories do so well? I thought I’d reflect on this a bit in public and also see what others think.

For one, I think there’s that whole “David vs Goliath” thing going on. Alongside that, there’s a similar “rich vs poor” or “rich vs middle class” or Robin Hood kind of story here. Utilities are rich semi-monopolies that have had a grip on our pocketbooks for ages. They also have a pretty huge influence over our policymakers. Electric utilities are the 13th biggest contributor to US Congress in terms of money donated. And they’re one of the least discriminatory — 40% goes to Democrats while 60% goes to Republicans. Anything that could dismantle the power of these megapowerful utilities is inherently a somewhat exciting topic.

Then there’s also the independence thing. Independence is a hot ideal within the US, and also in many other places. Solar power, clearly, gives us a bit more independence… or at least the ability to be independent. Furthermore, it gives us independence (or that potential for independence) from a somewhat faceless, vaguely known and understood, powerful body that we largely just see as taking our money.

A couple of lesser but still probably quite powerful concepts that I think make the solar vs utilities theme so popular are: 1) we are cutting pollution in favor of natural abundant, clean energy from the sun; and 2) this shift is part of another wave of technological transformation or revolution that gets some of us very excited. We read about the Industrial Revolution in our history books, but now we are in the midst of creating the Cleantech Revolution and the Distributed Energy Revolution. This is exciting stuff. We are creating history. And this time the result is a cut in pollution.

Those are my thoughts. What are yours?

This article was originally published on CleanTechnica. Reproduced with permission

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

  1. My thought is one that I remember from hearing Dr Helen Caldicott speak many years ago. She pointed out that “if they could put a blanket around the sun and sell holes in it, they would”.
    I think that it is simply offensive to the corporate mindset that anyone could get anything (such as sunshine) for free. The idea of free fuel is deeply disturbing to the corporate utilities.

    • Bob_Wallace 7 years ago

      No one likes their income reduced or eliminated. We shouldn’t be surprised that the fossil fuel industry and utilities that stand to lose business would push back against renewables.

      But in the end they will lose….

  2. Roy Ramage 7 years ago

    Solar panels are successful as they are an inclusive technology. Monopolies are not inclusive. You never change things by fighting the existing reality. To change things build a new model that renders the existing model obsolete. Hello solar!

Comments are closed.

Get up to 3 quotes from pre-vetted solar (and battery) installers.