If you need a PhD to read your power bill, buying wisely is all but impossible

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Energy bills are becoming to complex to understand, but we can learn much by analysing them closely. Here’s how..

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

The Conversation

A recent survey found that Australia’s power companies are less trusted than media companies, banks and telcos. Customers hate electricity bills – not least because they are so complicated. But we can learn much by analysing them closely.

One feature that deserves close scrutiny is the all-pervasive discount. In electricity retailing, all but 3 of the 28 active retailers use discounts in their retail offers.

In any kind of retailing, discounts give customers the impression that they are making a smart buy.

This is often true, particularly in cases where it is easy to see and compare the discounted prices.

But if it’s not easy to compare, customers may not realise if they’ve been duped.

With electricity bills, it is all but impossible for customers to know whether their discounted price really represents a good deal.

This is because the discounts are ludicrously complicated – as are the base prices themselves.

Large businesses do not complain about retail electricity markets. This is because they have the capacity, either in-house or through consultants, to evaluate complex retail price structures.

Advances in data science may yet make such expertise available to everyone.

Eye-wateringly complex

To fairly compare your bill, you must be able to adjust for the discount in your current bill, and also in all the alternative competing offers.

Having worked with thousands of bills, I know the myriad ways discounts are calculated make this terribly difficult.

Let us count the ways a discount may be applied:

  • some discounts are worked out as a percentage of usage charges while others are on the total bill
  • some discounts are before the receipt of concessions, others after
  • some discounts are before solar feed-in receipts, others after
  • few bills actually clearly state the discount rate, and some don’t state the rate at all
  • some discounts are only received on subsequent bills (so that if the customer leaves, the retailer avoids discounting their last bill)
  • some retailers offer several discounts in the bill but sometimes some apply after other discounts are taken off first
  • some will discount controlled load consumption, others not
  • some discounts are payable as rebates when the customer transfers to the retailer; other rebates are paid out over months and even years
  • some offer discounted amounts which are contingent on advance purchases of electricity, but the discount is not achieved unless purchases exceed the contingent amounts
  • some discounts in bills are not actually calculated in customers’ bills as the retailers say they are calculated
  • some retailers take up-front payments from customers and then feed those payments back to customers on each subsequent bill as if they are discounts
  • most discounts are conditional on customers doing something (usually paying the bill on time) but some are unconditional. Some bills have both conditional and unconditional discounts; others just one or the other.

If that isn’t enough, electricity tariffs in Australia are stunningly complex commercial arrangements.

They have daily charges and a wide range of methods for charging for consumption: flat rates; daily, monthly or quarterly block rates; time-of-use rates with two or three bands; combinations of time-of-use and block rates; one or more separate rates for controlled loads of different types; consumption rates that are seasonal; and now some bills with peak demand charges.

Solar feed-in rates offered by retailers often (but not always) vary depending on the receipt of subsidies. Most recently, some retailers have offered block rates for solar feed-in, or different prices for the first tranche of solar power feed-in.

What can you do?

It is no surprise that few customers have the time or skill needed to choose wisely.

While this is not a peculiarly Australian phenomenon – evidence from abroad shows that lots of money is left on the table even when customers try to buy well – we think it is worse here. Our research is working to quantify this in Australia.

Government price comparison sites, like Energy Made Easy, are often advanced as solutions. But a 2017 competition review found that these have had limited success in Australia and elsewhere.

Complexity trips up governments too, and retailers work hard to persuade the regulators and policy makers to their point of view.

Regulating complexity away through standardisation is also suggested. Tight regulation can work well; think of the excellent market for bread and patisserie in France.

But standardising the sale of electricity often comes at the expense of incentives for retailers to discover customers’ needs, and may increase rather than reduce average prices.

Policymakers want both customer protection and incentives to innovation. But the desire to have one’s cake and eat it can lead to half-baked solutions that make matters worse.

The solution may be to master the complexity rather than trying to regulate it away. Many existing price comparison websites offer limited coverage of the market of competing offers, or look at only the energy consumption portion of a customer’s existing bill.

However advances in data science now make it cost effective to provide small customers with on-going analysis of their usage and their retailer’s charges in order to ensure that they are always on the best deal for them.

Businesses using this approach overseas are well established, and the scope for further innovation is very large.

Overcoming the complexity of the retail market will take away the wool that retailers have a powerful incentive to pull over their customers’ eyes.

Source: The Conversation. Reproduced with permission.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

  1. Joe 1 year ago

    Energy Sharks playing smoke and mirrors billing games = Customer in a state of confusion with no real idea of what’s what. Just the way the Energy Sharks want it to be.

  2. Adrian Merrick 1 year ago

    We analyse a lot of customer bills and are always frustrated/amused that many retailers continue to use 4 decimal places in their unit rates. The value of a one digit change in the 4th decimal place is about half of one cent per year for the average customer. Data science is certainly an option, but it also carries a cost and it’d be a shame if customers can only save money through an engine that polices the market on their behalf. Perhaps if customers vote with their feet retailers will create products that can be easily compared. We flew against the wind when launching transparent prices with no made up discounts and got a lot of positive feedback, but a number of other customers do remain convinced that a conditional 20% off a 30c tariff absolutely must be better than a guaranteed 23c.

    • MaxG 1 year ago

      “only save money through an engine that polices the market on their behalf” however this engine is useless, as it does not take into account specifics.

  3. Chris Fraser 1 year ago

    Yes they are very complex. It helps to understand your historic, seasonal demand for each quarter, and then use a spreadsheet to plug in different tariffs from different retailers. Some use the daily access charge to claw back money and I’m very sceptical of them and discounters.

  4. Robert Westinghouse 1 year ago

    I use a spread sheet. It proves I am getting Donald Ducked each and every time.

    • MaxG 1 year ago

      Well, knowing this, it should be time to change :))

      • Robert Westinghouse 1 year ago

        Recently moved to Sonnen Flat….will see their bill, due very soon.

        • MaxG 1 year ago

          Oh dear; recently analysed their offer and concluded it (to be nice) a short end of the stick for the customer. Good luck.

  5. MaxG 1 year ago

    It is all about confusing the heck out of the consumer, which is actually quite easy to do given the general STEM skills in the population.
    I have heard people saying: I don’t bother checking as they are all the same scumbags. My reply: some are more than others. :))

  6. Ian 1 year ago

    Save the grief and don’t worry about all the mumbo jumbo.
    After years of frustration we simply chose a carbon neutral generator /retailer, who generate more zero emissions electricity than they sell. (Powershop) though there are other good ines Energy Locals and Enova.
    We are not rich but the differences in discounts and rates are not large in general perspectve and there are bigger things to worry about.
    That said, mumbo jumbo in billing should be outlawed.

  7. Craig Allen 1 year ago

    For the past two months I’ve been called several times a week by a mob calling themselves Energy Savers. They have no website and a poor grasp of English. They say that I am paying too much for my electricity and then want me to give them details of my electricity company, address and bill. I keep asking them to remove me from their database. My number is on the do not call register. I block the numbers they call me from. But they keep coming back from different numbers. Clearly some kind of scam. Makes you wonder how many sharks are successfully using the confusion to screw people over.

  8. solarguy 1 year ago

    It will be interesting in the future for retailers, once there is a critical mass of roof top solar and revenue dry’s up. They will need to reinvent themselves to stay relevant in a world of distributed energy.

Comments are closed.

Get up to 3 quotes from pre-vetted solar (and battery) installers.