Qld govt approves Tablelands wind farm, locals threaten legal action

A wind farm proposed for Queensland’s Atherton Tablelands has won state government approval, after years of delay and vocal opposition from a local anti-wind group.

The 225MW Mt Emerald wind farm – which would be the first large scale wind farm in the state – was given the green light on Friday by Queensland Deputy Premier and infrastructure minister Jackie Trad, with strict conditions including that the project’s 63 turbines be located at least 1.5km from any existing residence.

The wind farm’s developer, RATCH Australia, said on Monday they welcomed the decision, which would create up to 155 jobs, $150 million of direct investment into the Queensland economy, and improved electricity security for Far North Queensland, generating enough energy to power 70,000 homes.

“Over the past four years the Project development team and specialist advisors have worked with Mareeba Shire Council and State government to develop the best possible plan, construction process and operational protocol for this unique site with a very high wind resource,” said the company’s head of business development, Anil Nangia.

“We intend to work with the community to ensure locals benefit from the Project, for example through the establishment of a Community Benefit Fund.”

RATCH, along with project partners Port Bajool, have been seeking approval to develop the project near Mareeba for more than four years, but have come up against strong local opposition.

The Cairns Post reports that a community survey of residents living within 5km of the proposed site found 90 per cent opposed it.

In mid-2014, the former Newman government took over the approval process for the project, following a request to do so by the Mareeba Shire Council.

The project’s director, Port Bajool’s John Morris, then called on the state government to make a decision on the $380 million project by January 30, but this was further delayed when the state election was called.

Of course, the Coalition lost that election to Queensland Labor, which has promised to take the opposite approach to renewables than Campbell Newman and his team, and grow the industry across the state.

In a statement on Monday, Minister Trad said that approving Mt Emerald wind farm was in line with this promise, as well as with the Far North Queensland Regional Plan 2009-2031 energy objective.

“This project will employ up to 200 workers over a two-year construction period, with ongoing employment for up to 15 local workers over the life of the wind farm,” she said.

“This will generate direct and indirect economic benefits to the local, regional, and national economies.”

Trad also assured residents she had listened to their concerns about the development, and addressed them through measures including the setback rule and strict noise limits.

“As part of the approval, the State requires the proponent, Mount Emerald Wind Farm Pty Ltd, to comply with a number of strict conditions, including daytime and night time noise limits which are equal to, or better than, standards in other states like Victoria and South Australia,” she said.

But residents are still not happy, calling on the federal government to intervene, and threatening legal action via the locally-based Tablelands Wind Turbine Action (TWTA) group.

“We’ve got 2,500 people living within five kilometres,” said TWTA spokeswoman Lee Schwerdtfeger.

“We’ve got people in other states reporting major problems out to 10 kilometres, so that’s to do with sleep and all sorts of health issues.poster

“It’s just too big for an area that’s as intensively farmed as ours.”

The project is, indeed, subject to further approvals, including on flora and fauna from federal environment minister Greg Hunt.

Under Tony Abbott’s leadership, the federal government has not been the biggest fan of wind energy, and is currently overseeing yet another inquiry into the effect of wind turbines on human and animal health.

But Nangia said the company was confident of winning the federal approval, and then of sourcing the debt and equity to build the wind farm.

“RATCH is large power station and owner and operator,” Nangia told RenewEconomy in an interview. We will use some of our own equity and … (Australia’s banks) will be very happy to help finance this renewable energy project in northern Queensland.”

Nangia also noted that, while the wind farm did not require state or federal funding, it would benefit from the retention of the Renewable Energy Target (RET) currently being reviewed by the federal government.

Mareeba Mayor, Tom Gilmore, also welcomed the project’s approval, saying on Monday he was relieved the state government had made a decision.

“I think that the majority of the community are probably supportive, although I have no real understanding of that,” he said.

“The important thing … from my perspective, is the widening of the economic base for our Tablelands region and for the Mareeba Shire Council in particular.”

Comments

12 responses to “Qld govt approves Tablelands wind farm, locals threaten legal action”

  1. Alex Avatar
    Alex

    While millions of people live within 5km of a wind farm around the planet, Qld residents are more likely to be susceptible to the terrible “nocebo effect” due to their long exposure to the Bjelke-Petersen government. I have no doubt that the Cairns Hospital will soon be flooded with patients suffering from “Wind Turbine Syndrome”.

    1. your local firefighter Avatar
      your local firefighter

      Yes Alex; “the politics of envy” play a part and an obsession to drive a fossil (fuel that is) as far as they can to wreck the planet as soon as possible for the “now generation’s” narcissistic short term gain.

      1. Patrick Avatar
        Patrick

        R u really a firefighter??? or the local alp blogger .

    2. john Avatar
      john

      Right explaining nocebo effect that is when your perceived illness is fulfilled.

  2. your local firefighter Avatar
    your local firefighter

    A great decision; the voice of reason for Queensland after all disadvantage brought about by the Newman regime.

    Well done.

  3. john Avatar
    john

    As I said before there will be a lot of local resistance to this outcome.

    1. Coley Avatar
      Coley

      Offer them a coal or nuclear plant as an alternative;)

  4. Craig Allen Avatar
    Craig Allen

    I stopped off at the Windy Hill wind farm recently, which is near Ravenshoe, on the Atherton Tableland. They look kind of old fashioned and were spinning fast. But from the lookout that is close by you couldn’t hear any noise at all coming from them. The cows grazing below looked quite contented.

    1. Steve Fuller Avatar
      Steve Fuller

      Quite clearly your hearing is sub par and the cows, while appearing to be contented, were actually in a sub audible frequency bovine comatose state – a beneficial side effect of which is the production of soy milk instead of the usual cow’s milk.

      Please proceed to the nearest emergency centre as you will soon begin to disintegrate unless treated with the latest homeopathic remedies.

  5. john Avatar
    john

    There will be a sudden outbreak of effects from the wind farm all type of outcome including loss of sleep loss or hearing loss of ability to think hmm loss of any type of reasoning on any other salient level this is to be expected; especially when one takes into consideration the nocebo effect.
    I would ask please do a study on people near the area to find any effects that are able to be discerned.
    Do it now all around the area and do it in about 3 years time when the instillation is up and running and lets get some real information to see if there is any discernible difference.
    This can be a case study to actually find what are the effects of a wind farm.
    We now have a chance to do a study that will yield real information that is usable and of some value.
    I just ask do the study please.

    .

    1. David Boxall Avatar
      David Boxall

      John, the issue has already been studied to absurdity.
      For good or ill, the human mind is a powerful thing. Suppose I told you that you had been cursed by a sorcerer. If you’re susceptible, then you might worry yourself sick, attributing everyday aches and pains to the curse and imagining worse. You might even die.
      Your illness would be real. Your death would be real. The cause would not be sorcery, it would be your belief. As the one who convinced you that you were cursed, I’d be culpable.
      For sorcerer, substitute windmill. Those who spread needless fear are making people sick. They should be investigated and punished.

  6. Coley Avatar
    Coley

    “But Nangia said the company was confident of winning the federal approval, and then of sourcing the debt and equity to build the wind farm”

    An optimist if I ever heard one.
    I live next to a 14 unit wind farm, in three years absolutely no problems.

Get up to 3 quotes from pre-vetted solar (and battery) installers.