NSW energy minister sees no competitor to coal “for decades to come" | RenewEconomy

NSW energy minister sees no competitor to coal “for decades to come”

NSW Coalition energy minister says he’s prepared to legislate to “embrace new coal mines” to keep the state’s coal power stations burning for as long as possible.


New South Wales energy minister Matt Kean has again pledged his allegiance to coal – and to his federal counterpart Angus Taylor – declaring the fossil fuel “here to stay for decades to come,” via the mainstream media megaphones of both the Daily Telegraph and 2GB Radio.

In what the Daily Tele described as the minister’s “first in-depth interview on energy and climate change,” Kean read straight from the Coalition song-book on both topics, even giving a hat-tip to Tony Abbott’s Direct Action policy.

The crux of the Daily Tele interview is that Kean and the Coalition Berejiklian government are prepared to legislate to “embrace new coal mines” and keep the state’s coal fired power stations burning for as long as possible.

Kean has said something along the lines of this before – as Michael Mazengarb reported here in July. But this week’s effort goes all out, using text-book LNP double-speak on climate, and outright misinformation on renewable energy.

On the one hand, he tells the paper’s state political editor, his government is“committed and firmly focused on protecting the environment” and meeting its stated target of net zero emissions by 2050.

On the other, Kean wants to keep the lights on and drive down power prices, and doesn’t want to “place ideology before people”.

“The people of NSW want to protect the environment but not at any cost to their hip pocket,’’ he said.

And if that means “bypassing clunky planning laws to speed up approvals to re-open nearby coal mines” – those are the Daily Tele’s words – then so be it.

“Let’s not beat around the bush this morning, Ray. Coal is absolutely here to stay for decades to come in NSW,” Kean trilled to 2GB’s Ray Hadley in a radio interview on Wednesday morning.

“I will look to secure the coal supply for power stations like Mt Piper, to ensure that they will be able to continue to operate for decades to come.

“My policy decisions will be driven by two objectives: keeping the lights on and driving power prices down. And Ray, that’s exactly what we’re going to do.”

Never mind that the vast majority of current intelligence on the National Electricity Market transition says that Australia’s ageing coal fleet is increasingly unlikely to do either of those things.

As Giles Parkinson reported earlier this week, the very same Mt Piper coal generator in NSW “looked to have difficulty digesting its breakfast over the weekend, tripping off on two occasions,” while its other unit is also out of action.

And on prices, there is no contest. A benchmark study from CSIRO and the Australian Energy Market Operator confirmed late last year that the cost of new wind and solar – even with hours of storage – is “unequivocally” lower than the cost of new coal generation.

As for what Australia’s rapidly changing grid needs to boost relaibility and economy, it is not baseload coal.

“What is needed is highly flexible and fast responding power. This can come from a variety of sources such as gas, hydro, energy storage, and demand response. However, coal is not one of them,” Energy Synapse’s Marjia Petkovic explains here.

But why take the word of energy industry experts or market operators, when you’ve got Ray Hadley?

“You said earlier, Ray, that the best way to provide baseload energy into the system at the moment, that’s reliable and affordable, is coal, and right now, that’s the case,” Kean gushed on 2GB.

“But who knows, in 20, 30, 40 years time, there may be new technologies that will deliver cheaper, more reliable power sources. I don’t have that crystal ball. My focus is on making sure we keep our power stations open until that technology arrives.”

AEMO doesn’t have a crystal ball either, but it does have an Integrated System Plan, and some of the best minds working on the task of decarbonising the grid in the smartest and most economic way possible and in a way that won’t accelerate global warming.

And those “new,” cheaper and more reliable technologies Kean dreams of… someone should let him know they have already arrived, and just keep coming – even despite Australia’s mind-boggling political climate.

Only this morning Neoen Australia unveiled plans for a massive new wind, solar and battery project for South Australia, adding to its suite of renewable and storage projects in the country, and taking the total pipeline of renewable and storage projects in the state to more than $20 billion.

At least NSW will have more interconnectors, so it can accept excess renewables from South Australia, and excess solar from Queensland.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

  1. trackdaze 9 months ago

    They will be forced to import more sun and wind juice from Qld and South Australia as the coal clunkers die.

    • John Saint-Smith 9 months ago

      Well, that won’t be such a terrible thing for NSW consumers, its already cheaper than their old gold plated coal-fired electricity, that’s why they’re importing it now, practically 24/7. Nobody is forcing them to rely so heavily on these disgusting unreliable renewables. But you wouldn’t expect the NSW Energy Minister to know that would you?
      Or perhaps he does…

  2. Les Johnston 9 months ago

    I guess Matt Kean might one day ditch his crystal ball and look toward factual evidence instead. Must have had a power surge when Mount Piper had a blip.

  3. Ken Dyer 9 months ago

    The NSW Energy Minister is a dud.

  4. Miles Harding 9 months ago

    Quote from above:
    Kean …. doesn’t want to “place ideology before people”.
    Odd how he’s doing precisely that.

  5. Coley 9 months ago

    “But who knows, in 20, 30, 40 years time, there may be new technologies that will deliver cheaper, more reliable power“

    Just how thick is this bloke? They aren’t even “new technologies” they are here and now, driving out coal in most developed countries…here in the UK we will see our last CFPS close in six years time..if not even sooner..and this in the country that pioneered ‘coal fired’ technology.
    Buggerinell, I love Australia (and NZ) but some of your politicians make ours look reasonable intelligent….and that takes some doing, when you look at messrs Abbott and Costello….oops Corbyn.

Comments are closed.

Get up to 3 quotes from pre-vetted solar (and battery) installers.