Home » CleanTech Bites » Monash family appalled by Coalition’s “horse and buggy” approach to energy

Monash family appalled by Coalition’s “horse and buggy” approach to energy

The family of the John Monash have expressed their horror at the actions of Coalition backbenchers who have hijacked his name to promote their push for new coal fired power generators in Australia.

The family issued a statement on Wednesday expressing their dismay at the “anti-science and anti-intellectual” approach of the so-called Monash Forum, and their promotion of technologies from the “horse and buggy era”.

They said they have no doubt that Monash, a revered military leader and civil engineer who pioneered the use of brown coal in Victoria’s Latrobe Valley a century ago, would now embrace wind and solar rather than coal.

“It has come to our attention that a group of conservative politicians have formed themselves into a lobby group for coal,” they said in a statement, reported by the ABC.

This referred to the group led by former prime minister Tony Abbott, former deputy prime minister Barnaby Joyce, Coalition energy committee chair Craig Kelly and between 20 and 30 backbenchers, most of whom also reject the science of climate change.

Their manifesto, basically summed up as coal subsidies good, renewable support bad, can be found here.

“At the very least it was discourteous to use it without informing us,” the family statement said.

“More than that, we disassociate ourselves specifically from the forum’s use of the Monash name to give their anti-science and anti-intellectual argument an air of authority and we ask that they withdraw the name.

The family said he developed coal for power generation when it was the leading technology, but they are sure today “he would be a proponent of the new technologies, [for example] wind and solar generation rather than revert to the horse and buggy era”.

Great grandson Mark Durré, who spoke on behalf of seven descendants, later told ABC Radio:

“He wouldn’t have had a bar of that sort of thing (reverting to coal technology). He would be very much an advocate of that new technology.

“We must move forward with new technologies. If you think about what it was like 100 years ago, coal fired was the cutting edge technology,” Durré said.

“Nowadays it is wind and solar. To go back 100 years … if Monash had done that, that would put them back into horse and buggy era, if you see the analogy.”

 

 

 

 

 

Giles Parkinson is founder and editor-in-chief of Renew Economy, and founder and editor of its EV-focused sister site The Driven. He is the co-host of the weekly Energy Insiders Podcast. Giles has been a journalist for more than 40 years and is a former deputy editor of the Australian Financial Review. You can find him on LinkedIn and on Twitter.

Latest posts

S-curve modelling says renewables can kick coal out of Australia by 2032. But is this soon enough?

S-curve modelling says renewables can kick coal out of Australia by 2032. But is this soon enough?

In the race to renewables, the big question is whether “faster than we thought” is the same as “fast enough.” S-curves say we can do the first. Nothing in the modelling tells us we’re on track for the second.
“It’s a commercial system. And it has a customer:” Sodium-ion battery sale hailed as a first for Australia

“It’s a commercial system. And it has a customer:” Sodium-ion battery sale hailed as a first for Australia

The sale of a 100 kilowatt and 200 kilowatt-hour sodium-ion battery system is being claimed as an Australian first – and may herald next generation of storage tech.
Energy Insiders Podcast: Will the green bank save the Tomago deal?

Energy Insiders Podcast: Will the green bank save the Tomago deal?

CEFC boss Ian Learmonth explains why big wind projects may finally get delivered this year. Plus: Tomago aims for 100 pct renewables, and the big utility profits.
Balcony solar or building integrated PV? The emerging options for apartment dwellers and owners

Balcony solar or building integrated PV? The emerging options for apartment dwellers and owners

A Victorian parliamentary inquiry on apartment energy issues has recently reported and identified several issues that require urgent attention to address the failures of energy policy. One interesting issue that relates to both high rise apartments, and plug-in ‘balcony solar’, is where solar fits into apartment occupant energy costs.  High rise apartment buildings have very […]
18 Comments