German coal power generation falls to 10-year low

Renewables International

This year electricity generation from coal is down in Germany and last month only 14.45 TWh. This is not only a hefty 20% decline compared to the previous year, but also the lowest monthly coal power production in more than a decade.

In 2013, coal power generation rose by 2.2%. Gross power generation from coal power stations totaled 283 TWh in Germany. Almost 10% of this electricity, some 27 TWh, was consumed by the power stations themselves. The remaining 256 TWh (net generation) was supplied to the grid. It marked the second consecutive year of rising coal power generation. This sparked worries that coal power could return to pre-recession levels, and some commentators even began calling this short term development a renaissance of coal.

So far, 2014 does not follow this alleged trend. During each of the first 8 months, coal generators were unable to match or surpass the output of the respective month in the previous year (see chart below). As a consequence coal power generation this year is already down by almost 17 TWh, or 10%, on a year-to-year basis.

140908coal2013vs2014

 

A record low for coal power

While low coal power generation is not unusual for the late summer month, a 20% year-to-year drop is. The factors that have led to squeeze out of coal were a decline in foreign demand, an increase in wind power generation, a minor increase in both nuclear and gas power production.

140908coalLowestMonth0214

 

A closer look at the available historic monthly data going back to 2002 revealed that August 2014 was actually the month with the lowest coal power generation in more than a decade (see chart above).

Very nice, but …

This monthly low is certainly good news, but it is not an indicator of an overall rapid decline of coal power. Despite this year’s decline, coal power generation is still above the low levels seen in 2009 (223 TWh). If the trend of lower year-to-year consumption continues during the last four months of the year, 2014 could, however, still come very close 2010 levels (230 TWh). But clearly, more installed megawatts of coal power capacity will not necessarily lead to more megawatt-hours of coal power, as is often assumed.

The growth rate of renewable power sources, especially wind power, as well as the overall domestic and foreign demand for electricity generated in Germany, will determine how much coal power is generated in the coming years.You can find more in-depth information on the future of coal power in Germany in this paper on the nations coal conundrum.

 

Source: Renewables International. Reproduced with permission.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comments

3 responses to “German coal power generation falls to 10-year low”

  1. michael Avatar
    michael

    wonder how much truth in the reports increase in coal in France
    “And it is not just the emerging world that is turning to coal. For a generation, nuclear power allowed Germany to sit at the vanguard of Europe’s mission to control carbon emissions. But Fukushima changed everything. Germany has shut half its nuclear power plants and seems determined shut the rest It has returned to coal to fill the power gap.
    Some 2.7GW of new brown coal capacity since 2010 and another 8GW of black-coal capacity will be opened this year. That is about a third of Australia’s entire coal generating capacity, Kenyon-Slaney said.”

    1. Tim Buckley Avatar
      Tim Buckley

      Michael Kenyon-Slaney works for the coal industry – don’t believe what he says! He quotes that there is 10.7GW new coal generation capacity coming online over 2010-2014. But his 8GW estimate is double other industry estimates for 2014-2015 combined. Also, he conveniently forgets to mention that this is replacement capacity, as there is more aged coal fired capacity slated for closure over 2014-15 that there is new stuff being commissioned (8GW in total). I wonder why he didn’t quote capacity additions NET of closures? German coal capacity closures will accelerate into 2017/18, just refer to the result presentations last month from E.ON and RWE, they notify the regulatory of significant new coal-fired capacity closures 2-3 years in advance for planning purposes. Maybe Kenyon-Slaney didn’t know about this?
      A really telling point – 2014 coal-generation down 10% year-on-year year-to-date but Kenyon-Slaney picks Germany as the good news story?! But then didn’t I read on Renew today that China’s coal imports 2014 year-to-date are down 5.3% yoy. Don’t look to America – Bernstein this week forecast US thermal coal demand will be down 25% by 2020. Maybe a trend of structural decline that Kenyon-Slaney is missing?

  2. Brokelyn Avatar
    Brokelyn

    It’s too bad burning coal is going the other direction for the rest of the world.
    Scary days ahead.

Get up to 3 quotes from pre-vetted solar (and battery) installers.