Drought hits Indian coal plants and expansion plans | RenewEconomy

Drought hits Indian coal plants and expansion plans

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Despite the Indian Government’s determination to double or even triple domestic coal production, a new report warning the crisis could get far, far worse.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Despite the Indian Government’s determination to double or even triple domestic coal production, the power sector is now being hit by water scarcity – with a new report warning the crisis could get far, far worse.

A little over a week ago the operators of the 2100 megawatt (MW) coal-fired Farakka power station in West Bengal shut down five of the six turbines due to lack of water.

A few days later the 500 MW sixth unit was shut down as well. There wasn’t even enough water to supply the taps for workers at the plant or the adjoining township.

With the plant supplying five states, power network operators scrambled to cover demand. It is currently estimated there won’t be sufficient water to allow the plant to run until at least March 25, 13 days after the first units went offline.

The 1720 MW Raichur Thermal Power Station in Karnataka state has been hit by lack of water too. Since March 15 it has had to shut down several of its units indefinitely. With the power station shut down the plant operators are now running out of space to stockpile coal, more of which arrives by the day.

The problem is far larger than just the shutdowns of the Farakka and the Raichur plants: India is in the grip of a growing water crisis.

As of March 17 the Central Water Commission calculated water in 91 major reservoirs across the country was down to just 27 per cent of total storage capacity. This represents more than one-quarter less than the average over the last decade.

With the monsoon not due until June, the next few months could be very lean times for coal, hydro and gas power generators reliant on large volumes of water for boilers, cooling and to run turbines.

Water for power plants will either come at the expense of water for drinking, agriculture and other industries, or the power sector will be forced to do with less – or without – in times of low-flows.

While the lack of water for the Farakka power station is caused in part by the requirement under the 1996 Farakka Water Treaty to share water with neighbouring Bangladesh, the phenomenon of coal power plants being shut down due to lack of water is not new.

The 1130 MW Parli power station in Maharashtra state has been shut down since July 2015 due to lack of water. Five years earlier Maharashtra’s state-owned utility, MahaGenco, had shut down several units of the 2340 MW Chandrapur Thermal Power Station due to the impact of drought.

The construction of NTPC’s Solapur power plant in Maharashtra has been delayed due to huge question marks about where the plant will get water to run on. Water scarcity could severely undermine the plant’s financial viability.

A new report from Greenpeace – The Great Water Grab: How the coal industry is deepening the global water crisis (pdf) – notes if the Indian government continues to push the construction of more coal plants, the water crisis will grow significantly worse.

The report estimates over 170 gigawatts of coal power plants, representing 40 per cent of the proposed Indian coal fleet, are in areas that are facing high or extremely high water stress.

While dry-cooled power stations are technically feasible, they are more expensive, consume more coal and still require water for steam-raising to spin the turbines.

The current water crunch for some coal plants has been flagged for years by civil society groups.

In its August 2011 report Thermal Power Plants on The Anvil: Implications And Need For Rationalisation the Prayas Energy Group foreshadowed the construction of ever more water-cooled coal-fired power stations would cause “immense stress” on water resources in the areas immediately adjoining plants.

They also cautioned that, due to variations in annual rainfall, there was no guarantee year-round water would be available for power stations.

With the Modi Government focused on increasing generation from currently under-utilised plants by increasing coal supply and restructuring the finances of the near-bankrupt distribution utilities, little attention has been devoted to the looming water crisis.

The completion of more part-built coal plants is likely to increase conflict over increasingly scarce water, even as climate change makes the Indian monsoon increasingly erratic and unpredictable.

If the water crisis continues to deepen, it may be one more factor pushing the Indian Government to further accelerate its shift towards non-hydro renewables.

Bob Burton is the Hobart-based Editor of CoalWire, a weekly bulletin on global coal industry developments. (You can sign up for it here.) His Twitter feed is here. Ashish Fernandes is Senior Campaigner at Greenpeace. His Twitter feed is here.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

  1. Tim Buckley 4 years ago

    The Government of India’s recent decision to require the washing of hundreds of millions of tonnes of domestic coal will further exacerbate this situation. Financially distressed global coal companies and associated Australian government ministers peddling coal poverty PR spin ignores this inevitable constraint on ever more coal use by India. It is telling that the utilisation rate of coal fired power plants has dropped more than a third to just 50% in 2015, a clear “surprise” to forecasters (coal boosters) who assume ever more coal demand. Natural limits means the Indian government will further accelerate its push to promote grid and energy efficiency at the same time as it boosts a diversification of generation into its now cost competitive, domestic renewable energy resources. Sensible economic drivers support this government policy. Water stress is just one more stranded asset risk that the Australian government and ANZ have failed to anticipate. Lucky the Australian Superfund industry have moved early to manage this increasingly serious risk (not!).

    • FIFO69 3 years ago

      India has a tropical climate classification.

      Rainfall is generally 400–750 millimetres annually.

      Seems to me its a simple matter of building a few dams to enable capture, storage of this water if they wish to wash their own low quality coal.

      Alternatively they can choose to save money on infrastructure costs and environmental impact (both locally and globally) and import high grade Australian coal which will generate less CO2 emissions when burnt.

  2. onesecond 4 years ago

    It is not only India. In last years heat wave Poland struggled to supply enough electricity as the rivers ran low.

  3. Mike Dill 4 years ago

    Wind and solar PV do not require water. With a billion people, and
    limited fresh water, non hydro renewables just make sense.

    • Doug Cutler 4 years ago

      You can even deploy floating solar directly on existing water reservoirs. There can be installation cost savings plus it can cut the evaporation rate of the reservoir.

  4. Rurover 4 years ago

    There’s a delicious irony in this.
    The burning of coal leads to global warming, which in turn decreases water supply in countries like India, which means that it’s no longer possible to burn as much coal!
    A sort of self regulating system…but one that causes huge “collateral damage” to the planet unfortunately.

  5. Geoff 4 years ago

    can’t even believe that they are tossing up between water for power generation or water for the people. I know, and i’m pretty sure over 1 billion Indians know where that water should go…

  6. Rob G 4 years ago

    Nature killing coal fire power with droughts… talk about a fight back!

  7. FIFO69 3 years ago

    I wouldn’t put much faith in anything published by Greenpeace, hardly a credible and impartial source of information..

Comments are closed.

Get up to 3 quotes from pre-vetted solar (and battery) installers.