Abe visit may hasten ‘solar fuel’ exports from Pilbara

Following the signing of the Japan-Australia Free Trade Agreement on PM Abbott’s recent visit to Japan, Japanese PM Shinzo Abe will visit Western Australia and the Pilbara region this week.

The visit comes at a time when renewable energy, and hydrogen, are an increasing focus for Japan’s energy planners, and energy security is a major topic.

Abe’s visit will coincide with the 25th anniversary of the first shipment of LNG from the North West Shelf LNG project to Japan, andĀ will reinforce strong, long-standing traditional energy and minerals trade ties in the face of growing resource competition and heightened strategic tensions with China.

But the visit is also interesting in the context of efforts to reduce Japan’s reliance on fossil fuels, and to reduce the carbon intensity of Japanese industry.

Hydrogen is often dismissed as ‘the fuel of tomorrow, and always will be’. But the hydrogen train is moving. A recent report talked of a new breakthrough in the use of hydrogen. Ā It has huge potential for Australia to exploit its solar resources to deliver the fuel.

hydrogen carIn 2015, for instance, Japan will roll out 100 hydrogen fuel stations to support the launch by Toyota and Honda of hydrogen fuel vehicles in the Japanese market. Competitor Hyundai recently released its first production hydrogen vehicle into the California market.

Doubts about hydrogen are partly due to the current primary supply source – most hydrogen is split from natural gas (using a process called steam methane reforming), and there are also concepts for production of hydrogen from coal and other hydro-carbons.

The obvious question is, if the hydrogen is coming from gas or coal, how is there any cost or environmental benefit? You still need gas or coal, and you’ve added more processes.

But Japan’s Strategic Energy Plan, released in April, highlights (at page 71) the solution, and in doing so, the massive opportunity for Australian solar and other renewable energy in a carbon-constrained Japanese economy:

‘It is important …in the future, to produce hydrogen utilising renewable energy such as solar power, wind power, biomass, at home and abroad,” it wrote, adding it wanted to develop “large-amount storage or long distance transportation by advanced technology including hydrogen shipping vessel, organic hydride and converting toward chemical materials such as ammonia and liquefied hydrogen.”

Hydrogen has been produced from water, using electrolysis, for decades. Powering electrolysis of water by renewable energy effectively acts as bulk renewable energy storage.

Hydrogen is notoriously difficult to store and transport, but converted to ammonia, LNG or liquid hydrogen, it can be transported like any other fuel.

Japan’s Chiyoda Corporation has developed a method to use standard petri-chemical tankers for long-distance hydrogen shipment. As numerous studies in recent years have highlighted, the Pilbara region, where PM Abe’s visit is centred, has among the best solar resources in the world. Solar power in the Pilbara is already competitive with diesel in many locations.

Investigation of ‘solar fuels’, as they are known – storing solar energy in transportable form (gas or liquid) for use in electricity generation or transport – is an increasingly important part of solar research, because it has potential to unleash an entirely new, industrial scale of solar development.

Ivanpah-Solar-Thermal-Power-PlantUnshackled from domestic electricity supply, solar power could be developed at massive industrial scale to produce hydrogen, driving costs down even further and faster.

The processes involved, including conversion into transportable forms, benefit from a combination of solar electricity and solar thermal energy, presenting opportunities for large-scale solar PV and CSP (concentrated solar power).

It is known that Saudi Arabia is considering similar potential for is solar resources, as a hedge against reducing oil and gas reserves, and in Australia at least one group has plans for a feasibility study leading to a potential pilot demonstration plant.

The Australian project is mooted for the Pilbara, and would use solar fields to generate power, produce hydrogen through solar-powered electrolysis and then demonstrate conversion of the renewable hydrogen into large-scale, transportable form for shipment to Japan, where this ā€œrenewable fuelā€ could then be incorporated into Japanā€™s energy networks for use in electricity generation, transport and/or in fuel cells.

The Japanese Strategic Energy Plan highlights an exponentially larger opportunity; the prospect of storing the Pilbara’s virtually limitless solar resources, located right next door to Australia’s largest gas and ammonia export platforms, for export.

If the Australian Government is serious about its plans for the Northern Australia’s development as an energy export hub, here would seem to be the large-scale energy export industry of the future, with our good friend and energy partner Japan as the anchor customer for a renewable hydrogen market that, over time, could extend throughout Asia.

The Abe Government has expressed stronger support than its predecessors for continuing nuclear power – plans to follow Germany in shutting down nuclear were scotched following Abe’s election. But popular opposition to nuclear following the ongoing catastrophe of Fukushima means that even the Abe Government sees the limitations of nuclear.

Japan needs very large-scale, carbon-free energy supply that breaks reliance on fossil fuels. Australia intends to develop our north as an energy hub for Asia.For Japanese-Australian energy trade, what could be a better fit than solar hydrogen production in the Pilbara, for export on a major industrial scale?

Comments

14 responses to “Abe visit may hasten ‘solar fuel’ exports from Pilbara”

  1. wideEyedPupil Avatar
    wideEyedPupil

    Japan are a heck of a lot closer to the Mongolian deserts where they were said to be planning a very major series of solar arrays/ or CST plants.

    1. Matthew Wright Avatar
      Matthew Wright

      Yes but the security aspect with China on Mongolia’s doorstep could make Australia look like a lot more rosy for solar fuels in their eyes.

      That said I think electrification with indigenous local power supplies is the go and Japan should be sinking a lot more money into wind and solar and getting electric vehicles onto their roads. Hydrogen Fuel Cells will soon be known as Hydrogen Fool Cells

    2. michael Avatar
      michael

      …located right next door to Australiaā€™s largest gas and ammonia export platforms, for export…. does Mongolia have that?

  2. Andrew Thaler Avatar
    Andrew Thaler

    As long as the transport ships are Hydrogen Powered with some spinnakers fitted to harness the windā€¦ it might be a suitable idea.

  3. tokenpom Avatar
    tokenpom

    Eastern Australia could do likewise to provide a domestic Energy resource, by allowing one or two of the existing open-cast mines to flood, so providing a plentiful supply of water for Solar-powered electrolysis.

  4. RobS Avatar
    RobS

    I wonder how many countries would have to express wonder and awe at Australia’s cheap and plentiful renewable energy resources before it penetrated Tony Abbotts thick skull just how big the opportunity he is squandering is.

    1. Chris Marshalk Avatar
      Chris Marshalk

      Tony Abbotts too stupid to know he’s stupid.

  5. Winston Avatar
    Winston

    Giles, you’ve skirted around the issue of where the ammonia comes from and how it gets around.

    The ammonia is supposed to be a good, dense transport medium for hydrogen. The apparent breakthrough described here revolves around cracking the ammonia to release hydrogen.

    Let’s pretend for the moment that we can convince our parliamentarians that ammonia isn’t a hazardous substance after all and all the strict controls around its transport can be relaxed (material safety data sheet here: http://docs.airliquide.com.au/msdsau/AL068.pdf).

    Going back up the chain we wonder where it came from. It seems you make ammonia by reacting nitrogen and hydrogen gases at pressure (the Haber process). Great – that’s easy. But you need gaseous hydrogen to start with.

    Currently, the most popular method for making hydrogen is cracking of hydrocarbons (allow me to call them fossil fuels). Of course, you’d never do that because that would be taking a fossil fuel that’s got good transportation properties, running it through a bunch of inefficient processes, just to make another transportation fuel.

    The other method of making hydrogen is electrolysis, as Giles points out. But the very best efficiency you can get out of electrolysis kit is about 50% (that is, the hydrogen produced has 50% of the recoverable energy of the electricity that goes in). Now, if I have some electricity handy, why would I ever want to throw half of it away making hydrogen, when I can throw 15% of it away by putting it in a battery (battery charging losses + transmission losses)?

    That gap is why hydrogen will never be a renewable fuel. If we’re to wean ourselves off fossil fuels we need to maintain focus on the primary energy supply.

    Of course, we’re talking about shipping this ammonia fuel to Japan, and it’s hard to lay a transmission cable that far. But that seems a bit premature to me. It’s not like we have a surplus of renewable generation for making fuel for somebody else. Oh, and let’s not forget that ammonia is listed as “very toxic to aquatic life”. Good luck getting it over the high seas without spilling it.

    1. Biff Avatar
      Biff

      Agreed. I understand that we’re talking here about Japan obtaining energy from another country and that building an undersea power cable between here and there is either infeasible or uneconomic, but ammonia seems the wrong way to go. As you say, using electricity (whether from fossil fuels or renewables) to create hydrogen is pretty silly – you are better to use the electricity directly in a battery and skip the conversion losses. But if you need a liquid hydrogen carrier then methanol is probably better. You could potentially use the waste CO2 from existing power stations.

      One thing is clear, however. Given the population size, proximity, and island nature of Indonesia, Australia could be a renewable energy powerhouse for one of the largest countries in the world.

    2. Alan Roberts Avatar
      Alan Roberts

      Where does the H2 come from? Solar thermal high temperature (900degC or
      greater) steam electrolysis produces H2 with a conversion efficiency of
      50% or more. In other words if you burn the H2 produced you get 50% of
      the solar energy back. The primary energy supply in this case is mass
      depletion in the sun, the solar conversion efficiency is great and
      immediate as compared to the 200million year old stored solar mentioned
      above.
      Solar high temperature electrolysis was being successfully
      trialled in the 1970s. H2 would have been a renewable fuel by now and
      the planet’s climate more liveable except for the intervention of the
      fossil mafia – that is the 40year gap, the energy gap is a strawman.

    3. JonathanMaddox Avatar
      JonathanMaddox

      “Common industrial electrolyzers have a nominal hydrogen production efficiency of around 70% … maximum efficiency rate of 77.6% was observed for [traditional] power supply. The results of this experimental work show a 10% more efficient conversion process by using a transistor based power regulator.” http://www.electrochemsci.org/papers/vol7/7043314.pdf

      “The result is an electrolyzer running as a full cell at 1000 milliamp per cm2 at 80% energy efficiency.” http://www.greenoptimistic.com/2010/05/19/gridshift-electrolysis-catalyst/

      And why people seem so fond of ammonia as a liquid hydrogen carrier is beyond me. Methanol is just as easy to make… http://www.carbonrecycling.is/

      … and at a pinch, it should be financially worthwhile to go direct to fossil-fuel-identical (but very clean) synthetic alkanes, using the same technology as existing coal-to-liquid plants in South Africa and China, and gas-to-liquid plants in Borneo and the Arabian Gulf.

  6. Miles Harding Avatar
    Miles Harding

    I am celebrating this momentous announcement in the only way possible — with a slice of fruit cake!

    Giles, You should know a turkey when you see one. The problem with hydrogen sourced from renewables is two fold; it is difficult to handle and store and more importantly, the overall efficiency (fool cells or not) is so poor that more than twice as much source energy is needed as would be the case with a purely electrical system. Adding ammonia only makes this equation worse.

    Japan’s problem is that they simply can’t sustain their population and way of life that has evolved in the last 50 years. No amount of techno-fixes are going to get them though this century without a major disruption. I seriously doubt that their mega-cities will exist in a recognisable form in a hundred years.

    Sometimes RenewEconomy reads like New Scientist!

  7. Alen Avatar
    Alen

    Japan seem to be investing a bit into geothermal (Costa Rica) hopefully this free-trade agreement will also encourage other economic activity and lead to investment into our big but untapped geothermal resource.

  8. Ronald Brakels Avatar
    Ronald Brakels

    Toyota is one of the largest, or depending on which year one is looking at, the largest car company in the world. They are currently pushing hydrogen. I think this may simply be a deception because they want their hybrid car technology to be seen as the answer to high oil prices, not electric cars, and so they are currently making noise that hydrogen is the real future and not battery packs. And so there may be nothing to the whole import solar fuels thing and it may simply be a smokescreen. But regardless of how serious they are, the Prime Minister of Japan will act as a mouthpiece for Toyota the same way Tony Abbott Abbott works for fossil fuel interests. The difference being that Abe is more interested in what is good for his country as a whole than Tony who is willing to further damage the environment that Australia’s agriculture, tourism, and our very lives depend on in return for the support of a small but wealthy group.

Get up to 3 quotes from pre-vetted solar (and battery) installers.