Home » Electrification » Australia risks becoming “rust-bucket state,” says Kean, as regional electrification plans crush coal exports

Australia risks becoming “rust-bucket state,” says Kean, as regional electrification plans crush coal exports

New analysis shows Australia remains the world's highest per capita emitter from coal use.

Australia must seize the opportunity to take a slice of a trillion-dollar pledge by South Korea to electrify its steel industry as the country looks to kick imports of thermal coal by 2040, the head of the Climate Change Authority says.

Kean, in an exclusive interview with RenewEconomy on the sidelines at COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye, said South Korean plans to electrify its steel making sector alone would crush $6.5 billion of Australian coal exports to the North East Asian country.

“I met with the Korean delegation yesterday, and I was shocked to learn that they’re committed to be out of thermal coal by 2040,” Kean said.

“Now, that’s a huge market for Australian export coal. I think an annual revenue of around $6.5 billion every year. That’ll smash that to smithereens. So we need to prepare for that eventuality.

“That looks like creating the new supply chains and the new resources that their economy is gonna want in the future. So these changes are happening. We need to prepare for that. We cannot pretend that the export industries of the past are going to go on forever.”

The comments come as Climate and Energy Minister Chris Bowen, in his capacity as COP Co-President for Negotiations, is expected to make a major announcement of a bilateral deal with South Korea in the coming days.

Addressing Turkiye and Australia’s push to lift electrification 35% globally by 2035, Kean said the initiative was gaining momentum and could not come at a more significant time.

“We’re seeing in real time the risk of tying yourself to very volatile regions of the world for your energy security,” Kean said. “So electrification means producing electricity, you know, in your country, close to where you’re using it.

“That’s not only energy security, that’s national sovereignty, and I think that’s increasingly becoming important in this geopolitical, unstable time.”

Asked about his former colleagues in the Coalition, which has pledged to strip more than $30bn in support for renewable energy if returned to power, and One Nation, which has emulated US President Donald Trump in declaring climate change a “hoax”, Kean said that whether they like it or not, the world was changing

“You don’t need to believe in climate change to believe in capitalism,” Kean said. “The reality is that Australia’s fortunes, economic fortunes, are tied to the markets that have underwritten our prosperity for generations, and they are changing.

“They are changing notwithstanding the domestic politics, and we need to prepare for that eventuality. Otherwise, we risk becoming a rust bucket state.”

Kean’s comments come off the back of a report published in the scientific journal Clean Energy that found electrifying the global economy may be easier than anticipated.

The paper found that about two thirds, 61%, of fossil fuels burned today are lost as ambient waste heat, a problem that clean electricity did not face.

Lead author on the paper, Oxford University Professor Jan Rosenow said arguments that one unit of fossil fuel energy would need to be replaced with one unit of clean energy to deal with climate change were “misleading” and the transition may prove easier than anticipated..

“You don’t replace a barrel of oil with a barrel’s worth of electricity,” Rosenow said. “You replace it with about a third of that. Electrification doesn’t add to the fossil system. It hollows it out.”

Rosenow said concerns among India and developing countries, particularly in Africa, that the COP31 electrification push did not take into account their circumstances was fair, but said the approach should still be seen as an opportunity.

“Countries start from very different places, and a single global number shouldn’t be read as an identical national target,” he said. “The countries with the highest energy use per person and flat electrification rates should move first and furthest.

“But I’d encourage developing countries to see electrification as an opportunity, not an imposition. It means less imported fuel, less wasted energy and cleaner air.”

Rosenhow added that the electrification push at COP31 came at a critical moment in both the response to climate change and when the fragility of the world energy system had been exposed.

“COP has spent years arguing over phasing out fossil fuels, which frames climate action as giving something up,” he said. “Electrification frames it as building something better: cheaper bills, energy security, less waste.

“That’s a more positive and more practical agenda, and it’s well timed, with another fuel price shock reminding every importing country how exposed it is.”

Royce Kurmelovs is an Australian freelance journalist and author.

Related Topics

5 Comments