Home » Commentary » Climate leadership or COP out? The time is up on the Albanese government’s fossil fuel hypocrisy

Climate leadership or COP out? The time is up on the Albanese government’s fossil fuel hypocrisy

COP31 President of Negotiations and Australian Energy Minister Chris Bowen at the COP31 UN climate summit, in Antalya, Turkey. (AAP Image/Lukas Coch)

Some media reports suggest that Climate and Energy Minister Chris Bowen is leading a bold agenda at COP31, the international climate negotiations currently underway in Türkiye.

Bowen, who is president of negotiations COP31, released what is reported as an ambitious 18 page draft climate agreement four days ahead of the close of negotiations, an unusual move.

The early draft calls for an immediate transition from fossil fuels, and for developed nations to target net zero by 2030 and net-negative emissions by 2040. Some of these are highly unlikely to survive the many edits pending.

Bowen warned that “it would not be the final version of the document and was designed to spark debate.” It seems clear that some of that debate will be coming from Australia, which, in fossil fuel terms, is the equivalent of a global drug cartel kingpin in a world hooked on ice.

Australia is a top three exporter of coal and gas – the dealer in the gated mansion getting rich off the supply of the very thing that is killing the planet. Or just as disturbingly, the willing dupe of fossil fuel multinationals, allowing them free rein to exploit our sovereign resources while failing to extract a fair return through our tax and royalty system as a social dividend for Australians.

In any case, these resources need to stay in the ground if current and future generations are to have a liveable climate.

However, it is reported that Bowen has refused to commit Australia to phaseout of fossil fuels, instead highlighting the action Australia is taking to reach net zero and reform the economy.

Concerningly, he is deploying some dodgy logic to defend this position: ”There are two types of countries in the world, fossil fuel exporters and fossil fuel importers, and we’re all in it together. The idea that everything [is for] fossil fuel exporters is not one I support.”

Meanwhile, the utter hypocrisy of Australia’s position is apparent in the mealy-mouthed rhetoric about the ethical necessity for rapid climate action to ensure the continued existence of our neighbouring Pacific countries.

A case in point is PM Albanese’s speech at the COP leaders’ summit, during which he invoked the pleas of a  young teen in Tuvalu endangered by climate change-induced sea level rise. He forgot to mention that fossil fuels from the Pacific’s greatest friend, Australia, are implicated, or the repeated cuts that have been made to our foreign aid program over the last two decades.

We’ve been here before. In 2023 at COP28, the imperative to bring the fossil fuel era to close was recognised for the first time in the final meeting communique.

In that instance, it pledged to “transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems in just, orderly and equitable manner” and “accelerate efforts to phase down unabated coal power” – the reference to “unabated” coal power being a concession to the furphy that the burning of coal can continue using the debunked methodology of carbon capture.

Bowen stated categorically at that time that fossil fuels must have “no ongoing role to play in our energy systems” if the world was to keep 1.5°C alive. 

However, before and since that time, the Albanese government, in which Bowen is accountable for our efforts to tackle climate change, has approved close to 40 new, expanded or extended coal, oil and gas projects.

A week before the unprecedented High Court ruling on the Mt Pleasant coal mine extension, the NSW IPC approved Hunter Valley Operations coal mine extension to 2045, the largest coal mine extension in NSW history. This now requires federal environmental approval to proceed. Many are closely watching this test of the Albanese government’s bonafides on the end of fossil fuels.

A new report from Climate Analytics reveals that despite the Albanese government’s fine talk on climate, under the current approach, exported emissions from our coal and gas will remain largely unchanged by 2040 in the context of an escalating climate catastrophe. 

What remains unabated is the contradiction at the heart of the Albanese government’s climate and energy policy  – the ramping up of fossil fuels, for which future generations will pay dearly, even as we make major strides on clean energy and the green reindustrialisation of our economy.

The latest example of the latter is the bilateral agreement with South Korea on the sidelines of COP. This Green Energy Statecraft MOU commits our two countries to work together on bilateral decarbonisation, accelerate investment in green value-add industries and trade, and strengthen clean energy supply chains.

This comes at the same time as Climate Energy Finance is in Guangzhou attending the new China-Australia Low-Carbon Iron and Steel Dialogue 2026, following on from the ANU hosted China-Australia Steel Decarbonisation bilateral discussions last month.  

These efforts are not just commendable, they are essential to position the Australian economy for a prosperous clean energy future in the emerging net zero world, collaborating with our key trade partners to jointly solve for industrial decarbonisation.

But time’s up on the Albanese government’s climate pantomime of holding a hose while it’s throwing fuel on a burning building. The science is clear: there is zero room for new coal and gas, and an existential imperative to accelerate their phase-out. Surely its leadership role at COP31 should be the line in the sand.

Tim Buckley is director and AM Jonson is editorial director of Climate Energy Finance

Related Topics

4 Comments