rss
1

Germans love renewable energy – no subsidy backlash!

Print Friendly

CleanTechnica

Imagine this: your national and local economies are benefiting from a shift to renewable energy, your air and water are getting cleaner, your electric grid is becoming more democratized, you and your neighbors are benefiting financially from becoming solar power producers, you get to cast of the shackles of guilt that come from burning fossil fuels, and the whole world is looking up to you as the leader you are in stimulating a solar power market and bringing down solar power prices.

Surely, this all makes you want to change course 180° and badmouth the solar policy that got you there, right?

Of course not, but that’s what much of the US believes. That’s what fossil fuel and utility leaders in Germany and elsewhere are saying. That’s what conservative German politicians are saying. That’s what misinformed reporters are saying. But, quite frankly, that isn’t the case.

When you see talk of a “backlash to solar subsidies” in American media (all too common), you never actually see any polls or studies cited, do you? No, you simply receive quotes from conservative politicians, certain heads of the energy industry, sometimes anonymous sources in the energy industry, and professional disinformers.

Whenever I see a comment from an actual citizen, she or he is in full support of the policy that has made Germany a global leader in this arena. But, luckily, I don’t just have random comments to rely on for this article. I’ve got the results of a poll conducted by a major energy association representing 1,800 companies (companies in natural gas, electricity, heating, etc). The poll was focused on Germany’s “Energy Transition” or “Energy Revolution” (Energiewende). About 1,000 citizens were questioned in telephone surveys conducted in January 2011, January 2012, and June 2012. Let’s have a look.

90% of Respondents Said that Energiewende Is “Very Important” or “Important”

renewables-important-citizen-survey

The Majority (51–61%) of Respondents Said that Renewable Energy Growth Was “Too Slow,” while Another 30-33% Said It Was “Just Right”

Only 6–10% said it was too fast:

renewable-energy-transition-german-poll

Of Those Who Said It Was Too Slow,…

  • 41% said that was due to “Delays Caused by Policy”
  • 30% said that was due to “Blockade by Power Companies”
  • 20% said that was due to “High Financial Outlay”
  • 12% said that was due to “Too Little Funding”

why-renewable-energy-growth-too-slow-germany

59% of Respondents Said that Energiewende Has More Advantages for Industry in Germany than Disadvantages (Only 15% Said It Had More Disadvantages)

subsidies-support-industry-in-germany

And, from One of German Our Writers, Why Energy Prices Have Risen:

Respondents answered according to the following split:

  • 33.6% – corporate greed, monopolies, market failure
  • 22.9% — fundamental changes in energy markets (e.g. rising costs for fossil energy sources)
  • 7.9% — renewable energy subsidies

why-german-energy-prices-rise

So, the next time someone talks to you about the “solar subsidy backlash” in Germany, I think you know how to respond, or where to send them (i.e. to this post).

This article was originally published on CleanTechnica. Reproduced with permission

RenewEconomy Free Daily Newsletter

Share this:

  • Dave Johnson

    Now that I am retired I have much more time for hobbies, and one of them is studying German. As part of that process I spend a good bit of time following German news, and I see that, as here in the U.S., this sort of thing depends upon the source of the news. For example, when I look at Deutsche Welle I see what appears to be a fairly balanced set of reports on the subject. That is to say, there is both good news and bad news, which makes sense. In contrast, Der Spiegel never seems to have anything but bad news on offer, and I finally quit reading their articles, not simply because they appear to be down on renewable energy, but precisely because their mix of stories is statistically implausible. In addition, when, say, Angela Merkel makes a televised statement on the subject, it is hard to believe that anyone is faking that. So, I have to assume that either the entire German government is lying about the state of renewable energy programs, or that Der Spiegel is, at best, filtering the news. The irony is that the name Der Spiegel means The Mirror, but I’m starting to think their mirror comes from a fun house at some carnival.