Governments

Know your NEM: As rooftop solar soars, something is rotten in the state of Queensland

Published by

Wholesale electricity prices in Queensland have gone through the roof, and the high prices have dragged up prices in NSW too.

Figure 1. Pool price averages. Source: NEM Review
Figure 1. Pool price averages. Source: NEM Review

As we have been commenting here for months, transmission issues have seen Victorian generators unable to access these markets, and even South Australia, running largely on wind and solar, is seeing higher average prices in recent weeks.

Still, the high prices in Queensland are remarkable, given that nothing in particular is happening to demand.

Figure 2. NEM operational demand. Source: NEM Review
Figure 2. NEM operational demand. Source: NEM Review

When we look at prices by fuel it’s a bonanza in Queensland, even for solar and wind, with current spot prices way above LCOE.

On the other hand, in Victoria, were these prices to continue and be reflected in contract prices, generators would be in financial stress all over the place.

For the last 30 days, the price obtained by solar farms in Queensland is averaging $88/MWh and wind is $102/MWh, while the corresponding Victorian numbers are $12/MWh and $25/MWh respectively. Maybe it’s Covid restrictions …

Figure 3. Fuel weighted prices last 30 days. Source: NEM Review
Figure 3. Fuel weighted prices last 30 days. Source: NEM Review

I’m too soon back from Xmas to work out exactly why prices in Queensland are so high, but certainly demand for coal for export isn’t helping.

These prices are maybe 3x or more what a coal generator in Australia would hope to pay in a medium term contract. The problem for Eraring and likely Vales Point in NSW, with no long-term contracts, is very obvious. However, in Queensland the situation is more complex and will need to be revisited at a later date.

Meanwhile, variable renewable energy marches on

Across the NEM wind and solar have provided 29% of total energy requirements in the past 30 days and 78% of South Australia’s requirements. These are strong numbers, albeit at a seasonally strong time.

Figure 4. NEM production by fuel. Source: NEM Review
Figure 4. NEM production by fuel. Source: NEM Review

This year is starting with VRE (wind and solar) supply running at an annualised 10TWh above the level of last year.

Figure 6. VRE production by fuel. Source: NEM Review
Figure 5. VRE production annualised. Source: NEM Review

This increase is entirely due to solar of one sort or another, wind production is pretty much flat year on year with rooftop solar production running clearly above wind for the first time in the history of the NEM. Indeed rooftop is presently the second largest fuel source behind coal.

Figure 6. VRE production by fuel. Source: NEM Review
Figure 6. VRE production by fuel. Source: NEM Review

 

 

David Leitch is a regular contributor to Renew Economy and co-host of the weekly Energy Insiders Podcast. He is principal at ITK, specialising in analysis of electricity, gas and decarbonisation drawn from 33 years experience in stockbroking research & analysis for UBS, JPMorgan and predecessor firms.

David Leitch

David Leitch is a regular contributor to Renew Economy and co-host of the weekly Energy Insiders Podcast. He is principal at ITK, specialising in analysis of electricity, gas and decarbonisation drawn from 33 years experience in stockbroking research & analysis for UBS, JPMorgan and predecessor firms.

Share
Published by

Recent Posts

Energy Insiders Podcast: How to replace gas

The gas industry says we need more of the fossil fuel to prosper. Jarrod Leak,…

1 November 2024

Queensland LNP names new energy minister, nixes massive pumped hydro project

Queensland LNP to combine treasurer and energy minister role, as it moves quickly to stop…

1 November 2024

More records tumble as renewables hit new high and coal a new low

Rooftop solar propels renewables to a new record share of the main grid, and pushes…

1 November 2024

Broken Hill fiasco shows why we need to rethink the grid, and turn it upside down

Broken Hill is back on the grid, ahead of schedule. It wasn't quite Mad Max,…

1 November 2024

We need lots of wind as well as batteries to move peak prices lower

Wind has had the biggest impact on lowering prices in peak periods. But we need…

1 November 2024

Grazing sheep among solar panels could produce higher quality wool, study finds

The combination of solar farming and sheep grazing does not have a negative affect on…

1 November 2024