Small scale battery storage costs tipped to fall quickly

Print Friendly

Overcoming the challenge posed by the intermittent nature of renewable energy continues to be a major roadblock to high levels of renewable penetration and a stick with which doubters of clean energy can attempt to hit the sector. Battery and storage technologies are an obvious solution to this, but high prices have seen uptake and projects remain limited.

battery storage

Battery image from ShutterStock

An increasing number of researchers and analysts, however, are making bullish predictions for cost reductions for storage solutions and in particular battery technologies that – like solar PV – can be implemented on a distributed basis and can mobilise the equity of homeowners.

With 3 GW of solar PV and 2 million small scale renewable energy systems, according to the latest figures from the Clean Energy Regulator, it is clear that Australian households and businesses are adopting clean technology in a big way. With these economies of scale, system price reductions have also been a major consequence, with PV panel and system prices reductions having a transformative effect on the economics of solar power.

Some are now predicting that a similar dynamic will emerge with small scale battery storage systems. “We will have a significant cost decrease,” predicts Dirk Uwe Sauer, from Aachen University’s Electrochemical Energy Storage Systems group. Sauer says that economies of scale for both lithium ion and lead acid batteries will cut battery costs by one-half to two-thirds.

“Four years ago it was predicted that the prices for battery cells, if you buy large quantities as car manufacturers do, would go below €200/kWh for cells by 2020,” said Sauer. “What you see today is that prices are well below this. Tesla is probably buying battery cells from Japanese manufacturers for US$150/kWh.”

For storage systems in homes, where weight and volume restrictions don’t apply as they do to cars, lead acid batteries can also be applied. Sauer says here too major cost reductions can be expected. “In home systems today, lead acid batteries are sold to the end user at €150 to €200/kWh, yet battery suppliers for car starter engines are sold to automotive manufacturers for €25/kWh.”

Sauer says the difference is that the automotive lead acid battery suppliers produce at “high quantity production sites,” producing in the order of 5 million starter batteries a year. With sufficient demand, a manufacturer of this size could supply 500,000 10kWh residential storage systems annually.

Large quantities of storage systems could have a transformative impact on electricity demand from the grid. Mike Sandiford, from the Melbourne Energy Institute, at Melbourne University, argues that NEM consumption data is already revealing falling demand, both in gross and peak terms.

Sandiford says that this is leading to lower utilisation rates of grid assets. Large numbers of batteries being hooked up to PV systems in Australian homes would presumably accelerate this trend – which would be extremely worrying for utilities.

In fact, a proliferation of storage systems could actually make electricity grids themselves more unstable. Theoretically, if large numbers of 3kWh to 5kWh batteries were installed in one section of suburban grid, when they all became full – potentially early in the day – the resultant surge of PV electricity could overload the grid.

However, distributed storage could also play a role in serving the grid – either through taking surges in PV-produced electricity off the low and medium voltage grids and even through frequency control. For “unloading”, control strategies can be implemented to adjust the time of day and rate when PV electricity is fed into the battery and limit the feed into the grid.

Researchers from Munich’s Technical University and the Centre for Solar Energy and Hydrogen Technologies (ZSW) in Stuttgart are currently developing such battery control strategies. At the recent IRES conference in Berlin, these researchers presented the latest data from these approaches which reveal that PV feed in can be managed to minimise grid load, without affecting the PV-electricity self consumption capacity of the household.

In short, by creating a dynamic strategy by which a battery charges itself from a PV array and at what time of day, surges of electricity flowing onto low and medium voltage grids can be minimised, with the battery still becoming fully charged to then be discharged in the evening and night. Weather prediction data, household demand predictions and the grid condition itself are the data required for the formulate these battery operation strategies.

What is currently lacking for these strategies to be employed is an incentive or market mechanism to do so. Aachen University’s Sauer is hopeful that in Germany at least, utilities and policy makers are waking up to the potential of large numbers of distributed storage systems to provide a service to the grid, along with to the homeowner. “The large utilities think a lot about decentralised storage systems because they understand that these systems most probably will come if they want them or not,” said Sauer. “Now they are looking very carefully at how they can be a part of the game and they are also thinking about if they can be one of the big suppliers of such systems. If they install them themselves, they can use them much easier for grid services.”

So it looks like it will pay for utilities and regulators to take a close look at distributed battery systems closely. Certainly, it’s clear that with the meagre tariffs being paid for solar power generated by households compared to high and rising electricity tariffs they’re paying, householders are bound to look at storage themselves. And if batteries get cheaper fast, distributed storage could be set to make a big impact on Australian electricity grids and markets.


RenewEconomy Free Daily Newsletter

Share this:

  • sean

    Resulting surge could overload the grid? How? Inverters have strictly defined limits to voltage and frequency. Outside this, they switch off.

    • Chris Fraser

      I understand that is the case. They are good at regulating the signal that goes out, and switch off if they can’t find at least 6A on the grid. The article discusses the results from everyone putting out large PV generation at the same time, which causes problems.
      In an ideal world PV is allowed out onto the grid unregulated, which prefers clean PV generation – not some dirty, lossy and uncontrolled generation from large distances away. In an ideal world it should be possible to permit unfettered PV output on a grid, and the network manager be made to monitor and regulate outside sources of energy to stop cooking the grid.
      This technology exists and was needed to be installed yesterday. The conspiracy people say it hasn’t occurred because it doesn’t fit with the sales goals of large generators. It may still happen, but then we haven’t designed for the situation where PV alone is just too abundant – and causes problems. When and if this happens, all the household inverters need to be managed remotely.

  • JohnRD

    There is a logic that says that the batteries should be owned by the power retailer/distributor. This would allow battery output to be controlled by the distributor on the basis of amount stored, PV output and demand. The result should be a more stable grid and areduced need for high cost peaking power.

    • Bob_Wallace

      The option would be to use smart charging and let the grid determine when to charge. Charging times could be staggered if needed. More batteries could go into charge mode during supply peaks and drop out when supply is strained.

      Same with EVs. Let the grid determine charge time and give cooperative end-users better rates.

  • Ron

    If I am away with the fairies …please tell me.

    I have Pv’s on my roof and get about $300 a quarter refunds ( at the Qld 44c refund rate).

    Is it possible now or in the near future for this solar storage theory to occur. It use these solar export kw to split distilled water by electrolysis into Hydrogen & Oxygen. The theory is oxygen would be vented to atmosphere and the hydrogen compressed into LPG like cylinders on site and at night the hydrogen would power a hydrogen gas fuelled generator

    • stucrmnx120fshwf

      For household use batteries make more sense, by getting entirely off the grid, you wouldn’t just get a poor feed in tariff, you would stop having to pay the horrible supply charge. Think no electricity bill at all, as to hydrogen, a mix of refrigeration and compression, even storing in metal hydrides, as in vehicles, for bulk storage makes a lot of sense. As the price per kWh of solar power gets dramatically cheaper, than carbon dioxide emissions based power, eg., desert concentrated cooled, high and low frequency solar power. Then industry becomes interested, refrigeration is cheaper in bulk as it insulates itself more, a typical economy of scale effect, for liquid hydrogen, Australia, 75% desert as an island continent, with a tiny 23 million population. A quarter of our deserts could supply 2,500 times, as much power, as Australia consumes each year, that’s just 1,000 by 1,000 kms. A million by a million metres, or in other words a trillion square metres, say 1 kW per metre, 12 hours a day, 365 days a year, or 4 MWh per metre, times a trillion square metres. 4,000,000,000,000,000,000 Wh, or 4 PWh per year, enough to make a trillion tons of liquid hydrogen per year, remember solar power per kWh is around 1/200 th the price that it was in 1975, the Swanson effect. 1915-25 peak decade of the 2nd IR, 2015-25 peak decade of the 3rd IR, the UNSW’s 40% efficiency concentrated cooled dual cell technology is revolutionary.…/unsw-researchers-set-world-record-solar-energy-efficiency. This will allow such things as high rise agriculture, 3D printed building, vacum tunnel magnetic levitation railways at 3,000 kms (, Japan has just authorised, the start of construction, of a national magnetic levitation railway, tunnel system.)

      • Bob_Wallace

        I don’t know about where you live, but where I live there can be multiple days in a row without good sunshine. When people talk about the cost to store electricity for a day or two they seldom talk about the cost of storing electricity for four days. Or seven days

        Before you talk about the wonders of going off the grid make sure you’ve covered the entire cost. Running a backup generator is not cheap.

        (I’ve been off the grid for over 25 years.)

        • stucrmnx120fshwf

          Frustratingly, you make a very valid point, it can be cloudy for long periods, maybe we’re stuck with the utilities and large scale hydrogen storage. One way around it would be using gas, in a fuel cell, but the initial outlay is quite a lot. A problem with sending power back to the utility, is loss over distance is up to 70%, still coal has exactly the same problem. You’re right, some form of distributed smart grid, using medium scale battery storage, wind, gas to medium scale high temperature fuel cells. Gas fuel cells in the medium scale are cheap to build, but expensive to fuel, so they make a good solution to intermittent loss, of sun based current. Where the solar power, cuts the cost of gas fuel inputs.