Policy & Planning

Is that a carbon tree? Or just another policy thought bubble?

Published by

If green groups and political opponents were unimpressed with the Turnbull government’s 2017 Review of Climate Change Policies yesterday, so was the Twittersphere.

A day after the Coalition made its pre-Christmas climate data dump – which showed a disturbing rise in emissions – and announced that another two right-wingers had been appointed to cabinet by the man coal magnate Gina Reinhardt rates as Australia’s greatest farmer – Barnaby Joyce – reviews of the review started to surface.

Journalist Adam Morton Tweeted that it was “transparently political: uses the minister’s language, doesn’t bother with new policies, suggests biz can emit more.” Another Tweet wondered “who wrote this work of fiction?”

But our favourite Tweet was from Michael Mazengarb, who wondered what secret, magic technology was depicted in the graphic pictured below and above, taken from the 52-page review.


Suggestions so far have included a giant balloon, a bubble wand, and a front loader washing machine for cleaning coal.

We thought we’d open the question up to RenewEconomy readers: What is this mysterious carbon offset thingamy that will deliver zero emissions? Any guesses?

Update: we asked the minister’s office. Apparently it is a tree. We’re not to sure why the leaves all fell to bottom left.

Sophie Vorrath

Sophie is editor of Renew Economy and editor of its sister site, One Step Off The Grid . She is the co-host of the Solar Insiders Podcast. Sophie has been writing about clean energy for more than a decade.

Recent Posts

It’s OK to mention “fossil fuels” at COP31 – then we can talk about replacing them

Politicians too easily push to be more "realistic" by using words like electrification as a…

19 November 2026

“Three strikes:” Regulator suspends solar installer from rebate scheme, warns industry “we’re watching”

Clean Energy Regulator declares another accredited installer ineligible to install solar or battery systems under…

19 November 2026

Regional network operator wins ring-fence waiver to install first-of-a-kind light pole EV chargers

Network company wins permission to dabble in kerbside EV charging, this time to test a…

19 November 2026

Home battery trailblazer quietly enters administration, leaving Australian customers out in the cold

A home battery maker that once had grand plans for the Australian market has gone…

19 November 2026

Dirty data centres could rival coal power plants on greenhouse gas emissions: report

An analysis of nine data centres proposed for Australia shows they could create as much…

19 November 2026

French energy giant buys up big battery plans for the heart of the New England REZ

Big battery plans for the heart of one of the most promising and contentious REZs…

19 November 2026