Categories: CleanTech Bites

Origin lines up another attack on renewable energy target

Published by

Origin Energy, Australia’s largest energy utility, has launched a new attack on the renewable energy target, arguing that it is exceeding its mandate and should be wound back – to a point where little or no large-scale wind or solar farms are constructed out to 2020.

In a presentation to a Macquarie Group conference this week. CEO Grant King argued that Australia’s renewable energy target was already at 16 per cent of national demand, and suggested that to reflect a “true” 20 per cent target, its scope should be drastically reduced.

King presented the above graph to support his arguments. On the left hand side is its estimates of the amount of electricity demand, both real and forecast, and the make-up of renewables.

King argues that under this scenario only 9Twh more of renewable energy – both large scale and small scale – should be constructed under the renewable energy target, if it continues to exist.

If it is assumed that there is no further rooftop solar (unlikely unless it is removed from the scheme) this still represents a two third cut in the amount of large scale wind and solar farms that could be built out to 2020. If the figure does include small scale solar, it would mean virtually no large scale renewable energy projects between now and 2020.

This would be welcomed by the incumbent generators such as Origin and EnergyAustralia, as well as the state-owned generators such as Queensland’s Stanwell that want the target dismantled completely. They appear to have the ear of the government, and the industry fears it has the ear of the hand-picked and mostly anti-renewable RET review panel.

The argument presented by the utilities – and the Coalition – is one around costs to customers. In the table on the right on the above graph, King argues that the RET is adding $147 a year to consumer bills.

However, the table has angered renewable industry, who point out that state based feed in tariffs and energy efficiency schemes have nothing to do with the RET. And Origin has used old data to inflate the cost of the small scale scheme.

The REC Agents Association said the number of certificates has more than halved and the expected cost this year is closer to $24 than $67. “Origin’s figures are exorbitant, even if we allow for higher target last year,” said spokesman Ric Brazzale. Studies from the Clean Energy Council, Schneider Electric and others say the fall in wholesale prices offsets the cost of the certificates.

The real reason that utilities such as Origin are arguing against the RET – both large scale and small scale – is the impact of their incumbent generation. As this graph used by Origin shows, the combined impact of energy efficiency schemes, rooftop solar, falling demand, and increased large scale renewables is forcing black coal and gas out of the market.

King argues that in the “normal course” it would be expected that generators could better balance supply and demand and “restore reasonable returns to generation.” Most generators are not making any money at the moment, including brown coal generators in Victoria, black coal generators in Queensland, and some gas generators.

King said it was likely that much gas demand would be withdrawn from the market because of the rising prices caused by the creation of the LNG export market. That generation would be taken up by black coal. Origin last year bought two large black coal generators in NSW.

 

Giles Parkinson is founder and editor-in-chief of Renew Economy, and founder and editor of its EV-focused sister site The Driven. He is the co-host of the weekly Energy Insiders Podcast. Giles has been a journalist for more than 40 years and is a former deputy editor of the Australian Financial Review. You can find him on LinkedIn and on Twitter.

Giles Parkinson

Giles Parkinson is founder and editor-in-chief of Renew Economy, and founder and editor of its EV-focused sister site The Driven. He is the co-host of the weekly Energy Insiders Podcast. Giles has been a journalist for more than 40 years and is a former deputy editor of the Australian Financial Review. You can find him on LinkedIn and on Twitter.

Share
Published by

Recent Posts

Bowen launches bold climate agenda to send a message to “board rooms and living rooms”

Countries could be urged to phase out fossil fuels faster and developed countries to reach…

17 November 2026

Chart of the day: The world is trapping so much extra heat, it’s like Icarus flying closer to the sun

Here's another way to think about what warming our planet looks like – and why…

16 November 2026

Australia risks becoming “rust-bucket state,” says Kean, as regional electrification plans crush coal exports

Climate Change Authority says Australia must act to take a slice of the trillion-dollar pledge…

16 November 2026

CIS-winning solar-battery hybrid heads to IPC, sent by local objectors from hotly contested REZ

A NSW solar project has seen big changes since a gruelling public submission process in…

16 November 2026

Australian BIPV pioneer secures contract to supply solar glass cladding for Singapore building

ASX-listed ClearVue says the lucrative new order proves the company’s technology “can make solar disappear"…

16 November 2026

Home battery boom delivers jump in “substandard” installations, regulator finds, up to 2 pct deemed “unsafe”

The huge boom in home batteries under the federal rebate has prompted the Clean Energy…

16 November 2026