Categories: FeaturedSmart Energy

How big is Australia’s carbon bubble?

Published by

One of the biggest challenges for forward thinking types – and we  hope all our superannuation trustees are among them – is to identify the so-called mega-trends and calibrate their investment decisions accordingly.

Climate change, and the action that the world might one day take to mitigate its impacts, is one of them. Investigations into this theme that has led to the concept of the carbon bubble – the sudden impact of a major change in policies that leaves the value of untouched fossil fuels in the ground, and away from the stock market. For some companies, that could represent a significant portion of their listed value.

Various groups have had a guess at what this might mean for stock market valuations. The Carbon Tracker Initiative earlier this year warned of the potential of systemic risk from the exposure of investors to carbon-intensive listed firms. It noted that on London’s FTSE index alone, one third of the carbon exposure came from investments in the coal industry in Australia.

But exactly how much of that investment is really at risk, and what are the implications for investors. A new note to clients from Citi analyst Elaine Prior suggests a carbon bubble exists in Australia, but it might not be as big as some think at least in the listed sector, at least in the context of the overall market.

Prior estimates that around 3 per cent of the value of the ASX200 (currently worth just over one trillion dollars) relates to thermal coal for power generation. (Australian coal interests actually account for around 4 per cent of the total share market value, but thermal coal is the commodity at risk, Prior says, because coking coal (used in the making of steel) has no immediate technology substitute).

Prior says the value at risk might be between 1 and 2 per cent of the ASX200, and that will depend on the timing of any action. Although this translates into valuations of $10-$20 billion, it doest represent between one third and one half of the value ascribed to thermal coal investments.

As Prior noted in a 2009 report, which canvassed various scenarios for Woodside Petroleum and the now delisted Coal & Allied – around half of a company’s value relates to deposits that might be 10 years from exploitation. Around one third relates to assets that might be 15 years from exploitation.

However, she noted that every company, project and set of assumptions will yield different conclusions. “In ballpark terms, even if thermal coal use declines dramatically in 10-15 years time, only 1-2 per cent of ASX200 value appears potentially “at risk”. In reality, low cost, high quality producers with good export infrastructure may fare better during a transition away from coal.”

And, she noted, some companies may benefit from alternatives, including those who produce uranium or gas in a coal constrained world, or from construction renewable energy generation.

Companies exposed to thermal coal include BHP Billiton and Rio Tinto, Wesfarmers, coal miners such as Aquila, Bathurst Resources, Coalspur, and Whitehaven); companies involved in coal fired power generation such as AGL Energy, and a raft of mining services, engineering, explosives and transport companies such as Asciano, Ausdrill, Boart Longyear, Bradken, Downer EDI, Emeco, Incitec Pivot, Leighton Holdings, Macmahon, Monadelphous, NRW Holdings, Orica, QR National, Transfield Services, UGL, and WorleyParsons.

Of course, there are a number of companies with much wealth that are not listed, such as those within Gina Rinehart’s and Clive Palmer’s business empires. They might not take kindly to having one third or one half of the assumed worth of their thermal coal assets written off at the stroke of a pen at international climate talks.

Giles Parkinson is founder and editor-in-chief of Renew Economy, and founder and editor of its EV-focused sister site The Driven. He is the co-host of the weekly Energy Insiders Podcast. Giles has been a journalist for more than 40 years and is a former deputy editor of the Australian Financial Review. You can find him on LinkedIn and on Twitter.

Giles Parkinson

Giles Parkinson is founder and editor-in-chief of Renew Economy, and founder and editor of its EV-focused sister site The Driven. He is the co-host of the weekly Energy Insiders Podcast. Giles has been a journalist for more than 40 years and is a former deputy editor of the Australian Financial Review. You can find him on LinkedIn and on Twitter.

Share
Published by

Recent Posts

Chart of the Day: Oil’s not well in the US, where bowser pain keeps nudging car buyers towards EVs

The strategic oil stockpile in the US has hit near record lows, so don't expect…

17 November 2026

SwitchedOn podcast: Households are changing the energy system, but can the system keep up?

Australians are embracing electrification, but policy, industry and infrastructure need to match their ambition.

17 November 2026

“Deep contradiction:” Report finds Australian coal and gas export emissions will not budge by 2040

Fossil fuel emissions from Australian gas and coal exports will largely remain the same by…

17 November 2026

Is Cheaper Home Batteries safe? Chalmers flags “fine balances” and no big cuts to “responsible cost-of-living relief”

Federal treasurer offers very small sign that Cheaper Home Batteries might be safe from major…

17 November 2026

“Masterclass in hypocrisy:” Australia bags another Fossil of the Day award for endless embrace of coal and gas

At COP31, Australia wins yet another Fossil of the Day award, this time for "writing…

17 November 2026

Over-size, over-mass and under pressure: Logistical barriers could delay wind projects by up to three years

New report warns Australia's straggling wind project pipeline could be delayed even further by inadequate…

17 November 2026