Markets

Frydenberg slapped down on Twitter after ignoring coal failure

Published by

Federal energy and environment minister Josh Frydenberg joined the Twitter frenzy about soaring NEM power prices during Thursday’s heatwave conditions, but from an entirely different angle to most.

While much of the social media conversation around yesterday’s eye-watering NEM prices focused on the fact that a unit at the newly purchase Victorian coal power plant, Loy Yang B, had tripped and failed just when it was needed the most, Frydenberg opted for a bit of political point scoring, with the Tweet below.

It did not go down well.

Here is a selection of comments Tweeted in response to the minister, including from energy market experts, analysts and players …

And the final word, though not via Twitter, goes to ITK analyst and regular RE contributor, David Leitch:

“Is Josh Frydenberg forecasting that South Australia will never have high prices again if/when Snowy 2 is eventually built? If so, I’d like a small bet with him on that. In any case it’s a bit irrelevant because Snowy 2 is still a long way away and will need an awful lot of high price events to make a return on capital.

“As for the NEG not sure how it would make any difference since no one, probably including Mr Fydnenberg, yet knows how it will work in practice, if it is ever adopted.

“In any event it appears that the interconnected flow from Heywood dropped down at the critical time and this was responsible for the high price. If this is the case, Snowy power couldn’t have got to SA anyway.” (See pink line in attached graph. Red line is price; blue is gas supply; yellow is wind; green is PV and pink is interconnector; black the battery.)

Source: NEM Review

Also, adds Leitch, “it looks the Victorian price was also high in the same period which probably means Victoria didn’t have enough power spare to send to South Australia. So if Snowy had operated maybe that might have made a difference to Victoria and so to South Australia. On the other hand, by the time Snowy is up and running there will be much more supply in Victoria as well.”

Sophie Vorrath

Sophie is editor of Renew Economy and editor of its sister site, One Step Off The Grid . She is the co-host of the Solar Insiders Podcast. Sophie has been writing about clean energy for more than a decade.

Share
Published by

Recent Posts

“Grand Theft Antalya:” A climate heist, or should we stop expecting COPs to call time on fossil fuels?

A global compact on phasing out fossil fuels seems increasingly unlikely as COP31 crawls to…

20 November 2026

Energy Insiders Podcast: On the ground at COP31

IGCC's Anna Hancock offers on-the-ground insight into what has – and hasn't – been happening…

20 November 2026

“100 towers raised:” State ticks off major transmission milestones, kicks off helicopter wire stringing

State's build-out of major new transmission projects hits important milestones, including 100 transmission towers in…

20 November 2026

Fire service thanks wind farm workers for “quick action” on neighbouring hay shed fire

Country Fire Service praises the "quick action" of 20 wind farm workers from an un-named…

20 November 2026

State orders rooftop solar switch-off, asks for patience, as wild storm cuts power to 24,000 properties

Around 24,000 South properties have been cut off from power – and rooftop solar switched…

20 November 2026

Big batteries to boost reliability over summer, says AEMO, as extreme weather meets changing demand

More than 6 GW of added big battery capacity will help Australia's electricity grids rise…

20 November 2026