Dud weather forecasts prove a headache for AEMO, particularly in biggest load centre

Published by

One of the key aspects of managing the electricity grid is knowing what supply is available, and what the demand is likely to be. Weather forecasts are a key component of both, but it looks like Australia’s Energy Market Operator has been getting some dud advice, particularly in winter, but also in heatwaves.

A new report quietly released on the AEMO website this week reveals that one of its weather forecasters was dumped last year because they weren’t up to scratch, but the error rate of the replacement and the other existing providers is still causing concern, especially when it is cold.

It turns out that one of the biggest headaches is in Penrith, in western Sydney, where the error rate is the highest. That’s a problem for AEMO because that area drives the biggest residential load in the country’s main grid.

Another problem area is Adelaide West, where AEMO reports that all its weather forecasting providers regularly over-forecast. “The systematic over-forecasting bias is evident for all providers in extreme cold temperatures,” it notes.

This matters because big errors in forecasts can have an impact on the grid, and cause a scramble to ensure enough capacity is available to meet demand.

One example was in Queensland in early July last year, when extremely cold conditions took the forecasters, and the market operator, by surprise. Variations in temperature forecasts, clouds and demand – the state recorded its highest winter demand of 8,716MW – created problems.

AEMO was caught out, and on both July 4 and July 5 it had to declare “lack of reserve” forecasts, and on July 5 had to trigger its emergency reserve trading mechanism and demand response (where customers are paid to reduce load) to ensure there were no outages.

This graph below illustrates the difference between demand predictions – based on weather forecasts – and the reality in Queensland on those days.

The AEMO report reveals some interesting foibles from the weather forecasters.

“Provider B” – the one brought in to replace the previously underperforming provider – emerged as the best performing forecaster across 4 hour, 24 hour, and 72 hour forecast timeframes.

But it also performed the worst in one hour time frames. Perhaps they forgot to look out the window, although that might not have changed much because it was the “early hours of the morning” where it was weakest.

Provider A – hitherto wobbly in the one hour forecasts – managed to lift its game in that department during last year’s winter, at least in comparison to the previous year. Provider C was consistent with the previous year.

AEMO says its response to this problem is to continue work with the providers to ensure that their tools are fit for purpose for energy forecasting, and to adopt a “probabilistic” approach to resource adequacy, and to include “uncertainty margins” in its reserve calculations.

It also wants to improve the observational network around the renewable energy zones that are being created across the grid to improve forecasting, and improve the tools assessing likely changes in output of variable renewable energy, particularly distributed solar PV.

It is also investigating the direct use of solar irradiance in demand forecasting to capture increased electricity demand caused by the heat island effects in major metropolitan areas.

And it will review the “provider weightings” in the Demand Forecasting System (DFS) “with the aim of increasing the contribution of Provider B in the resultant demand forecast.” At least it seems satisfied with its choice of new provider.

Giles Parkinson is founder and editor-in-chief of Renew Economy, and founder and editor of its EV-focused sister site The Driven. He is the co-host of the weekly Energy Insiders Podcast. Giles has been a journalist for more than 40 years and is a former deputy editor of the Australian Financial Review. You can find him on LinkedIn and on Twitter.

Giles Parkinson

Giles Parkinson is founder and editor-in-chief of Renew Economy, and founder and editor of its EV-focused sister site The Driven. He is the co-host of the weekly Energy Insiders Podcast. Giles has been a journalist for more than 40 years and is a former deputy editor of the Australian Financial Review. You can find him on LinkedIn and on Twitter.

Share
Published by

Recent Posts

“Grand Theft Antalya:” A climate heist, or should we stop expecting COPs to call time on fossil fuels?

A global compact on phasing out fossil fuels seems increasingly unlikely as COP31 crawls to…

20 November 2026

Energy Insiders Podcast: On the ground at COP31

IGCC's Anna Hancock offers on-the-ground insight into what has – and hasn't – been happening…

20 November 2026

“100 towers raised:” State ticks off major transmission milestones, kicks off helicopter wire stringing

State's build-out of major new transmission projects hits important milestones, including 100 transmission towers in…

20 November 2026

Fire service thanks wind farm workers for “quick action” on neighbouring hay shed fire

Country Fire Service praises the "quick action" of 20 wind farm workers from an un-named…

20 November 2026

State orders rooftop solar switch-off, asks for patience, as wild storm cuts power to 24,000 properties

Around 24,000 South properties have been cut off from power – and rooftop solar switched…

20 November 2026

Big batteries to boost reliability over summer, says AEMO, as extreme weather meets changing demand

More than 6 GW of added big battery capacity will help Australia's electricity grids rise…

20 November 2026