Solar

Damages dispute between contractor and owners of NSW solar farm at standstill

Published by

The drawn out dispute between one of Australia’s biggest listed contracting companies, Decmil, and the owners of the 200MW Sunraysia solar farm in NSW is at a standstill, pending the completion of works and commissioning later this year.

The dispute between Decmil and the owners – UK infrastructure investment John Laing (90 per cent) and Australian company Maoneng – first erupted in 2019 following delays in the solar farm’s registration and connection and commissioning.

The news of the dispute, and the potential damages, caused a slump in Decmil’s share price and a decision to follow other major contractors out of the EPC contracting business. Decmil is still involved in the renewable construction industry, but as a specialist contractor.

Sunraysia finally obtained its R1 registration in December last year, about a year after mechanical completion of the project, and Decmil said oil Monday it is currently at hold point 3 stage testing.

Decmil said the legal battle between the parties is ongoing, but proceedings are currently stayed pending “substantial completion” of works due by November 30. This is presumed to be full commissioning at the rated capacity.

The dispute is centred around claims for extensions of time, variations, payment of liquidated damages, return and reinstatement of security and claims concerning alleged defects.

Decmil said in an investor presentation accompanying a new fund raising on Monday that it views the liquidated damages, recourse to security and set-off is wrongful

It also revealed that its fiscal year 2020/21 earnings will be impacted by a $9.7 million reduction to the “accounting contract” position.

It still insists that there are a range of future accounting outcomes to the dispute, between an incremental contract profit (or loss) of minus $19 million to plus $10 million.It says the potential cash settlement in favour of Decmil is between $0 to $29 million.

John Laing, which encountered a number of problems on its portfolio of wind and solar farms in Australia, including connection delays and restrictions due to grid congestion, and big losses on the investments, is in the process of selling its wind and solar investments.

It has already sold its wind portfolio in Australia and has put the sale of the solar portfolio, which also includes the Finley solar farm in NSW, on hold until the Sunraysia dispute is sorted and grid issues are clarified.

Maoneng is continuing with a range of projects, mostly in battery storage, including a contract with AGL to supply 200MW/400MWh of battery storage, including at Sunraysia, and two big battery storage projects in South Australia and Victoria.

Giles Parkinson

Giles Parkinson is founder and editor of Renew Economy, and of its sister sites One Step Off The Grid and the EV-focused The Driven. He is the co-host of the weekly Energy Insiders Podcast. Giles has been a journalist for more than 40 years and is a former deputy editor of the Australian Financial Review. You can find him on LinkedIn and on Twitter.

Share
Published by

Recent Posts

Akaysha inks revenue swap deal for Queensland big battery with commodities trader

Akaysha Energy signs "sophisticated" revenue swap deal for its new Queensland big battery with a…

21 February 2025

Mount Isa turns to wind, solar and gravity storage to save city as big mines close

Mount Isa is looking to green energy and gravity storage in its disused mine shafts…

21 February 2025

Energy Insiders Podcast: Why is the green energy transition made to sound so hard?

Climate 200's Simon Holmes a Court on the upcoming election, the role of independents, lessons…

21 February 2025

Peter Dutton’s nuclear accounting trick #3: Hide the costs of keeping coal

The Coalition’s nuclear plan takes a gamble with our electricity system that old coal will…

21 February 2025

Indigenous-owned energy retailer branches further across NEM, supplies power to NBN

Australia's first Indigenous-owned energy retailer is expanding into two more states just eight months after…

21 February 2025

NSW announces review into transmission planning as it plots route to renewables and storage

NSW announces review into transmission planning in possible move to have more say about what…

21 February 2025