Why Top Gear may be the most dangerous TV program on the planet

Published by
Shuttershock
Shuttershock

It’s time to ask a few questions about the BBC’s re-launch of Top Gear in a post-COP21 world. Top Gear has achieved the status of a cult show, and is one of the most widely, watched television programmes on the planet. It also happens to make a considerable amount of money for the BBC.

The problem is that this light and laddish offering is hugely influential and no doubt the auto and oil industries are not unhappy to see their products on it. It’s effectively a vast free advert for the vehicle and oil industries.

The elephant in the studio is that the oil and vehicle industries are precisely those that need to be transformed for the sake of the earth and its inhabitants. The days of mindless petrol-headery should be numbered but the BBC doesn’t seem to have noticed.

But in fact the BBC knows all this. The Corporation puts out some splendid environmental programmes. And precisely because of that, there is a weird disconnect going on at Bush House. A programme is aired one day on how fossil fuels are changing the climate and then on another day Top Gear comes across as if the climate crisis didn’t exist. Frankly, Aunty Beeb sometimes doesn’t seem to know which planet she’s living on.

Jeremy Clarkson has gone, but not before he took the Mickey out of environmentalism and electric cars. According to George Monbiot of the Guardian his tactics in criticising electric vehicles were simply dishonest. His article paints a damning picture of an organisation which doesn’t observe its own ethical code.

It will be very interesting to see if Top Gear changes its tune under its new anchor Matt LeBlanc. The car companies, oil people and petrol-heads will be hoping it doesn’t change. Wiser heads will be looking for a more critical offering. If it’s not forthcoming it will be high time to hold the BBC to  account.

Chris Chatteris is a freelance journalist based in South Africa.

Share
Published by

Recent Posts

Chart of the Day: Oil’s not well in the US, where bowser pain keeps nudging car buyers towards EVs

The strategic oil stockpile in the US has hit near record lows, so don't expect…

17 November 2026

SwitchedOn podcast: Households are changing the energy system, but can the system keep up?

Australians are embracing electrification, but policy, industry and infrastructure need to match their ambition.

17 November 2026

“Deep contradiction:” Report finds Australian coal and gas export emissions will not budge by 2040

Fossil fuel emissions from Australian gas and coal exports will largely remain the same by…

17 November 2026

Is Cheaper Home Batteries safe? Chalmers flags “fine balances” and no big cuts to “responsible cost-of-living relief”

Federal treasurer offers very small sign that Cheaper Home Batteries might be safe from major…

17 November 2026

“Masterclass in hypocrisy:” Australia bags another Fossil of the Day award for endless embrace of coal and gas

At COP31, Australia wins yet another Fossil of the Day award, this time for "writing…

17 November 2026

Over-size, over-mass and under pressure: Logistical barriers could delay wind projects by up to three years

New report warns Australia's straggling wind project pipeline could be delayed even further by inadequate…

17 November 2026