Bill shock; we all dread the quarterly electricity bill and my first one under the July 2013 increase has just come in.
Being a hopeless geek, I quickly uploaded the data to my spreadsheet, called my utility to understand the incomprehensible gibberish cunningly described as “a bill” and managed to understand what they were talking about. This bill is particularly confusing because it’s crossed over the financial year rate rise; I pity the un-geeks in this world because “confusion is profit” never rang more true.
Duly following the links on the bill, I also located the comparative rates under different scenario’s – Flat rates and Time Of Use, which I volunteered for a year or two ago. I recall the reaction of many friends and colleagues when TOU was introduced which ranged from “what the ^&**(&*$#?” to “$0.45ckWh? Are they kidding? Who would agree to that?”, to even more colourful phrases. Undeterred, I have stuck with it as quasi academic exercise; and the results are now bearing fruit.
For comparison, in my area my TOU rates are now:
If I elected to change to a flat rate:
So on face value, I wondered what the hell am I doing?
There are a few interesting things that I learned though.
Firstly, given that I had to pay for my meter to be installed and it’s fully digital (compared to my old rotary meter), I’m quite perplexed that I am charged almost 12% more per day for the “privilege” of being on TOU. In concert with the quite scary $0.478ckWh peak rate, I’m not surprised that most people take a quick look and decide not to sign up. For all the bluster about trying to incentivise demand savings clearly, my utility could give apparently two hoots. There is NO price signal in this equation that would attract anyone in their right mind after a cursory glance.
The other disincentive I hear from punters and electricity folks is that TOU price signals have limited traction; people do what they have to do when they have to do it. I can testify to that because with 3 kids and a busy life, my better half manages to work miracles and is aware, but barely focused on when electricity is used. On top of that, in our rental property we have little option but to use small electric heaters in strategic spots to warm our cockles in winter. We do our best and always see a surge in winter but still manage to keep our gross consumption down to under 12kWh/day, which is around half the comparable average.
I’m a bit more focused on it of course, and took another couple of steps this year by putting centralised, remote control standby switches in. We abandoned them after a month because they kept eating batteries, not working, or resetting the TV/Stereo system every time they were switched on and off – the cost of the irritating phone calls to make it work was far beyond the savings and marital greif. I remain optimistic that there is a better system out there, but haven’t found one yet. I also added a programmable timer to my electric bike so that I’m recharging in off-peak periods only, which saves money but doesn’t utilise my solar for recharging. Net CO2 compared to my combustion engined bike is still miles better and I do use solar for recharging on weekends, so i can live with that for now.
So TOU IS a signal, even to the non geeky types in our house and it IS having an impact. Our behaviour has changed.
What about the financials you ask?
We’ll even with our clumsy lifestyles and a higher daily access charge, we manage to save a little over 2% on our total costs on TOU rates. So it works financially too. I’ve graphed it so you can see the comparisons below.
My kingdom for a utility who can innovate!
Energy expert Gabrielle Kuiper on getting the best out of distributed energy resources in the…
Australian households could lower their bills by over two thirds if they fully electrify their…
Blackout featured prominently in media headlines this week, but not on the grid. But as…
Trinasolar and Mint Renewables have now both lodged planning applications for neighbouring big batteries in…
Greens make last minute commitment to vote for $22 billion Future Made in Australia policy…
Andrew Forrest's Squadron Energy seeks green tick for new wind and battery project in NSW…