Coalition climate policy built on little more than “hope,” says BNEF

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

BNEF says Turnbull’s climate policy built on “hope” that economy could “accidentally” decarbonise. Penny Wong laments a lost decade.

Credit: AAP Image
Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Credit: AAP Image

The head of Bloomberg New Energy Finance in Australia has slammed the climate policy of the federal Coalition government, describing it as being built on little more than “hope.”

Speaking at the Carbon Market Institute’s 2018 Emissions Reduction Summit in Melbourne on Tuesday, BNEF’s Kobad Bhavnagri said that – at a time when good policy was most desperately needed – the Turnbull government seemed to be using a faith-based approach to decarbonising Australia’s economy.

“The path now looks really quite clear: for one-third or potentially more of the world’s electricity to be zero carbon by 2030; one-third of light trucks and light vehicles to be electrified by that time; and for the global economy to be one-third more (energy) efficient.

“That is the new business as usual,” Bhavnagri told the conference.

Meanwhile, in Australia, “the (federal) government’s approach to meeting the 26-28 per cent national emissions reduction objective by 2030 is hope.

“A hope that the economy will just continue to more or less accidentally decarbonise,” and hopefully, he added, with the help of “some fluke technologies that we can adopt from other places.

“And everybody in industry should worry deeply about this approach, because it is many of your companies that will need to close for this to accidentally happen,” Bhavnagri said.

“The upshot is, that this strategy has actually worked so far, to achieve the very weak 2020 (emissions) target, which we’re now on track to do, thanks to some favourable accounting treatment.

“But this isn’t very good policy.”

But Bhavnagri wasn’t entirely dismissive of the Turnbull government’s efforts to effect policy change.

“On the upside,” he said, “what’s happening in the energy sector does have some cause for optimism, and the mechanism that is being developed by the National Energy Guarantee actually looks strong.

“It looks like it has the capability to achieve the required emissions reductions … and it does display an innovative method which manages to not upset some of the crazies that reside in the government’s benches.

“But of course the target is very, very weak. And (a target of 26 per cent reduction in emissions for the power sector) is a problem for not only the power sector, but also for the rest of the economy.

“Because the power sector is really on track to achieve about a 23 per cent reduction on 2005 levels, thanks to existing policies, thanks to the RET and the rollout of rooftop solar.

“So between 2020 and 2030 over a decade … about a 3 per cent reduction is set to occur, which is pitiful for the power sector and will be done on a business as usual basis.

“The thing that should concern everybody in this room, is that the lack of (emissions reduction) in the power sector transfers that burden to other sectors of the economy … which don’t have the technology which is already economic… to readily decarbonise.”

And Bhavnagri wasn’t the only speaker at the Summit’s morning plenary to speak plainly on the shortcomings of policy makers.

The head of energy and environment at the International Energy Agency, Dave Turk, told the Summit that the 2017 uptick in global emissions, while not unexpected, should be seen as a wake up call for governments all around the world.

“We are not nearly having the policy signals we need around the world” Turk said, if we are any chance of keeping global warming at or below the 2°C mark scientists say we must aim for.

ALP Senator Penny Wong, who also spoke, was also – predictably – critical of the government’s climate record.

Wong, who was climate minister when the Rudd government’s CPRS was derailed in 2009, has also watched the former Gillard government’s Clean Energy Future repealed by the Coalition.’

“I keep waiting for someone from the BCA (Business Council of Australia) to tell me why it’s a great big tax on everything,” quipped Wong – who is now shadow foreign minister – at the start of her talk.

She said that Australia had effectively lost a decade in the race to prevent dangerous climate change, thanks to political ideology and a federal government that “can’t countenance” renewable energy.

“But I hope we’ve learned our lesson. Because it’s harder now.

“What have we achieved after a lost decade. From a national perspective, we’ve increased the cost of the transition – that’s fundamentally what we’ve done. …We’ve made everything harder,” she said.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

  1. John Mitchell 2 years ago

    Always said that these FOOLS are only guessing. With the average IQ of minus 10, you cannot expect anything else from a bunch of BUFFOONs.

  2. Ren Stimpy 2 years ago

    “Hope” is the wrong word. These Liberal politicians are individualistic selfish morons. They don’t give a fu–dge about the common good, only about their own wealth and individualistic prospects. These Liberals don’t give a flying FUCK about the broad appeal and prospects of Australian society! It’s all about their own government-enhancd ability to get ahead of the rest.

    • John Saint-Smith 2 years ago

      Have you ever noticed how early politicians retire in Australia? That’s so they can reap their real rewards from ‘post politics posts’ as ‘advisors and board members of peak industry lobby groups, promoting fossil fuels and dirty energy, sugar, and ‘almost live animal exports’.

      • Ren Stimpy 2 years ago

        I have. Who knew that these stolid reps were in it all along to reap their own selfish individualistic benefits?

        Government in our country is surely FUCKED.

  3. Rod 2 years ago

    I do wonder if Ms Wong might be …..incorrect.
    Given the huge reductions in the price of PV and wind in the last two years, the mad monk may have actually helped us install much more RE than would have happened without his delaying tactics.

Comments are closed.

Get up to 3 quotes from pre-vetted solar (and battery) installers.