Solar makes EV battery support for the grid complicated financially

Print Friendly

Renewables International



Yesterday, we discussed a new project in Germany, in which electric vehicles provide ancillary services to stabilize the grid while these cars are charging. Today, we focus on some of the findings.

First, the good news: the project enables EV owners to earn up to 500 euros a year, depending on how much battery capacity is made available. The downside is that the battery is worn down in the process – quite considerably.

“Providing grid services for the secondary reserve [which kicks in after 30 seconds to stabilize the grid frequency at 50 hertz, ed.] is basically the same burden on the battery as driving the car is,” explains Detlef Beister of inverter manufacturer SMA. However, the services provided by the EV can be defined so that they remain reasonable.

The provision of primary ancillary services is different. Here, large amounts of energy are not put into or taken out of the battery for extended periods. Instead, small and large amounts may move, depending on need, but only briefly. As a result, the battery’s rated output is more crucial here than its total storage capacity. “The load on the battery for the provision of primary services is below 10 percent,” Beister estimates.

If the car is also charged from a solar array, connections to the market for ancillary services become really complicated. “You additionally have to take into account whether it is better at a given moment to provide the service to the grid or consume the solar electricity within the home instead of paying the retail rate and consuming from the grid,” explains Gero Lücking of German green power provider Lichtblick.

The technician who optimizes the overall system for the owner of the array and electric vehicle then have to decide in which order what will be done: charge the array’s battery first and then the electric car and then fell to the grid, or charge storage partly and then start taking part in the ancillary services market?

With German retail rates now around 25 cents per kilowatt-hour, “the focus will first be on directly consuming solar electricity, including charging the car, to offset purchases of grid power. Only then does it make sense to think about business models for EVs providing ancillary services,” Lücking says.

“Models that are easier than participation in the secondary services market will probably be created for the integration of vehicle batteries, because once you have control of that, you can use all other optimization models.”

 The project has already revealed that there are no technical hurdles for such market integration. Once bidirectional charging has been established, it will become interesting for businesses and municipal utilities. The former will use their vehicle fleet to cover peak loads, thereby saving significant costs. Municipals will, in turn, create swarms of EV storage units as an energy service.

Unfortunately, German carmakers are not yet on board. No German electric vehicle currently supports bidirectional charging. But there are such cars from Japan. For instance, Nissan integrated bidirectional charging in the first generation of its electric cars. Toyota and Mitsubishi now also offer this function. The Germans have some catching up to do.

Source: Renewables International. Reproduced with permission.  

Share this:

  • john

    Charging up an EV during the day at perhaps lower cost of power than in the peak which is now is the evening and plugging that EV into the system to then deliver perhaps only 20% of its power is very beneficial because it reduces the cost of power at that time to all users.
    Now looking at charging up that EV I said charged during the day so use PV to charge it.
    This is not rocket science it is simple plug the EV into a PV charging network during the day then when the EV gets home plug it in to help the network with pretty simple control system that will ensure it is not sent to low State of Charge that will cause damage to the battery system.
    Just imagine if in a community that 20 people could plug in and give about 10 kwh of power that would be 20*10 = 200 KwH of power usage.
    Is that in any way useful?
    Looking at a 30 household usage of power with 20 suppling some power.
    Demand 30 about 8 KwH each total 30*8 = 240 KwH
    Supplied power from those batteries = 200 KwH
    Result not exactly a huge demand only 40 KwH which will put down price to buy power.
    What is needed either home backup batteries or a good system control system to allow an EV with its battery system to augment the power demand of the grid.
    Question does anyone see any company looking at this??
    My thoughts absolutely no one because that is off the horizon of their perspective.

    • MaxG

      Keep dreaming… with those idiots at the helm they can’t fathom such an approach, let alone implement it :))